As state general fund dollars are decreasing, and demand for government services remains strong, departments, agencies and boards are turning to the Legislature in the ongoing regular session and asking for millions of dollars in fee increases—not tax increases.
It’s an important distinction, since lawmakers are unable to raise taxes in an even-numbered year, like this one, unless they’re in a special session.
That creates a bit of a pinch for lawmakers in the ongoing regular session. The budget being drafted for the next fiscal year that begins on July 1 is short some $750 million from being fully funded. The assumption is that lawmakers will return for a special session after the regular session adjourns to try and drum up the money through tax increases, but the public bodies in need of that money don’t seem content to sit and wait.
Both the Department of Health and Hospitals and the Department of Environmental Quality have introduced massive fee packages for the regular session. The Department of Agriculture is also looking to gain authority to set new fees for allowing advertising on department property.
But that’s only the beginning. There are also proposed new fees or fee increases that would apply to all state courts, the Office of Motor Vehicles, cemeteries, fishing guides, drones, pipeline operators, clemency investigators, architects, medical records, notaries, oyster farmers, court reporters, crab fishermen, hunters, school bus drivers, insurance consultants, electric vehicle owners, oil companies, learner driving permits, contractors, birth certificates and death certificates. A very small handful of these items have already been spiked in the regular session, but the vast majority of the proposals are still on the move.
Lawmakers in the House had a hard time reaching a 70-vote threshold for taxes during the first special session of the year, and some are already finding it difficult to support large fees as well in the regular session. There will be plenty of opportunities for this debate to play out. As of last week, nearly 80 bills addressed fees in some way, of which more than three dozen increase existing fees or create new ones.
Some of the political strife involved surfaced last week over Rep. Julie Stoke’s HB 700, which would allow DHH to generate $2.6 million in new revenue annually by creating and increasing fees. Amendments were attached to the bill, which will change the overall financial haul, but concerns by committee members were enough for Stokes, R-Kenner, to temporarily shelve her legislation.
“In my opinion, raise a tax or raise a fee, is basically the same thing. I see that as what we’re trying to do here,” said Rep. Rogers Pope, R-Denham Springs, of HB 700. “It’s a mechanism to get around a way to raise revenue for a department that has absolutely taken a hit. I get that. But we’re raising fees on an individual. Every person that we have in the state will have to pay this. Now why can’t we do it in a tax? Because it won’t pass. That’s obviously the reason.”
The bill creates a permit fee for food and beverage vendors at Jazz Fest, doubles to $6.40 an annual water meter assessment on every household and establishes other fees for restaurant re-inspections and individual sewer systems. It’s expected to come back up for a vote this week at some point along with Stokes’ HB 699, which raises an additional $1.3 million a year for DHH through licensing and bed fees for pain management clinics, therapeutic group homes, crisis receiving centers, ambulance services, home-based service providers and other facilities.
The debate we’re likely to hear most is whether a tax is being disguised as a fee in the regular session. Technically, a tax is a charge on goods and services implemented by the government to raise money. A fee, on the other hand, is in theory a similar charge, but in Louisiana it can only be used to recoup the cost of what is being provided to the payer.
Some of the proposed fees this year are sizable. For example, HB 446 by Rep. Bernard LeBas, D-Ville Platte, would create a $5,000 minimum fee for medical marijuana pharmacy applications. It’s one of the single biggest fees moving in the regular session.
As expected, colleges and universities are in the mix as well as they face deep budget cuts. HB 586 by Rep. Steve Carter, R-Baton Rouge, and SB 80 by Sen. Blade Morrish, R-Jennings, would allow public higher education boards the ability to make one-time tuition and fee increases.
All of this has ignited a side discussion over whether the Legislature should be able to raise taxes in any given year, as opposed to odd-numbered years only. The Senate and Governmental Affairs Committee approved SB 25 this week, which is a constitutional amendment from Sen. J.P. Morrell, D-New Orleans, to do just that by making all sessions fiscal sessions.
“Sometimes, like this year, we are going to have tremendous financial situations pop up,” Morrell said. “Tying our hands and saying that we have to hold expensive and short-sighted special sessions to deal with our regular fiscal matters just doesn’t make sense.”
So for now, it’s all about the fees. Until a second special session is called, at which point it’ll be all about taxes again. Either way, it eventually means more money out of the pockets of individuals and businesses. That should at least prompt a larger discussion about the role of government in our lives and the critical services it provides.
—Jeremy Alford
Jeremy Alford publishes LaPolitics Weekly, a newsletter on Louisiana politics, at LaPolitics.com. Follow him on Twitter, or on Facebook. He can be reached at JJA@LaPolitics.com.
