Skyrocketing insurance premiums. Increasing industry regulation. A frozen housing market. Ever-tightening credit.
Robert Clegg, owner of residential contractor Penn Construction, has seen this combination of market forces push a number of his colleagues and friends out of the industry in recent years.
“Several have just quit. They just couldn’t make it work anymore,” he says. “There’s a lot of stuff going on that is making it harder and harder for a licensed contractor to go to work every day.”
It’s gotten to the point where Clegg, who’s been in the business for nine years, doesn’t see how a new contractor could possibly get a start.
“You’d either have to have a lot of money put away,” he says, “or you’d have to be unlicensed and flying under the radar.”
The Louisiana State Licensing Board for Contractors believes the economy is forcing the latter to occur at a historically high rate. The number of licensed residential contractors in Louisiana has dropped about 25% since the recession began, from roughly 400 to 300, LSLBC Public Information Officer Kris Fitch says. Applications for new licenses, she adds, also have decreased.
“Let’s talk reality. Does that mean fewer contractors are out there working? No,” Fitch says. “Our opinion is that they are working. They’re working unlawfully, and that’s accounting for the majority of complaints we’re receiving.”
Allegations about unlicensed residential contractors filed with LSLBC have reached an all-time high, Fitch says, in part because there are more unlicensed contractors in operation and also in part because of additional spending on public education campaigns to combat contractor fraud.
“We have to combat the unlicensed contractor, because they’re competing with the wholly licensed contractors who are paying all the high costs” of being licensed, bonded and insured, Fitch says. “When you don’t have to pay those high premiums, you certainly don’t have to charge as much as a lawfully licensed contractor would.”
Clegg spends as much as $80,000 a year on required liability, workers’ compensation and builders’ risk insurance. He hasn’t knowingly lost any jobs to unlicensed contractors, he says, but he knows a number of subcontractors who have been hung out to dry by them. Still, he says, it’s the consumer who is most threatened by unlicensed builders.
“If something happens to the house, it’s not insured,” Clegg says. “There’s no warranty with an unlicensed contractor.”
That’s the message LSLBC and Louisiana Attorney General Buddy Caldwell have teamed to promote. Fitch and Caldwell cite Hurricane Katrina as the turning point after which their offices began working together to educate the public about hiring a contractor and spotting fraud.
Along with increased advertising, resources for consumers have been expanded and enhanced online. LSLBC’s website has been updated to include complete company license checks and complaints. Caldwell’s office has developed a standard contract and brochure with consumer tips. He says the public is responding.
“You probably only had one out of every 10 cases being reported before, and now you’ve got five out of 10 being reported,” he says. “You’ve got a much more educated consumer now. Unfortunately, a lot of people had to learn the hard way, but they have learned.”
Caldwell and his team of investigators have recovered about $2.4 million in 1,100 criminal contractor fraud cases since Katrina. Though statistics are not available by year or by case, Caldwell says, the Katrina-related caseload peaked in 2009. His office, however, has seen an increase in unlicensed contractor complaints as the economy continues to recover from the downturn.
Caldwell says his approach to combating unlicensed contractors is the same as his approach to all fraud: consistent resolution and restitution for victims.
“What I want to do is deliver. I want to help people get their money back,” he says. “I want to do such a high-quality job that unlicensed contractors are scared to come to Louisiana. Take that to Mississippi. Take it to Alabama. But you better not come to Louisiana because we’re going to make it tough on you, and we’re going to get our money.”
In 2009, legislation increased the potential fine unlicensed contractors face in civil cases from 3% of the total project value to 10%. It also made criminal contractor fraud punishable by up to five years in jail.
Tougher penalties, paired with continued economic recovery, should help decrease the number of unlicensed contractors, Fitch says, but there’s no telling when the market could turn around.
On the commercial side, complaints about unlicensed contractors have not risen noticeably, Louisiana Associated General Contractors CEO Ken Naquin says, because there’s little or no market for commercial contractors.
“We’re very skittish, because there’s just very little private money for commercial developments out there,” he says. “I see 2011 being worse than 2010, and 2012 as possibly being worse than 2011. Unless we find some additional revenue sources, we could be facing some tough times just like the residential guys.”
Robert Denk, assistant vice president for forecasting and analysis with the National Association of Home Builders, has a sunnier forecast for the Baton Rouge and Louisiana markets. NAHB data shows the area’s homebuilders are back to about 70% of prerecession business, a figure that ranks among the best in the nation. Still, he admits, it won’t feel like a drastic turnaround.
“This is one of the markets around the country that we think has the most potential for an early and strong recovery,” Denk says. “It’s not going to look like robust recovery for Baton Rouge, but it will look like a better recovery compared to other states.”
