Under the knife

Author Profile Image
Sign up for the free Daily Report email – local news about the people, companies and issues that impact business impact business in Baton Rouge and beyond.

Dr. Darryl Peterson is an orthopedic surgeon. But he’s also a small-business owner, with an office in the Greater Baton Rouge Surgical Hospital that he shares with three partnering doctors and 30 employees.

At the same time, Peterson is a father of two children who are preparing to graduate college, as well as a son of parents who rely on Medicare. So, he says, the impacts of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act hit close to home.

“I’m surrounded by this thing 360 degrees every day,” says Peterson, whose wife, Dr. Lydia Sims, is an obstetrician at Woman’s Hospital and Baton Rouge General. “There’s not a day that goes by that someone doesn’t want to talk to me about it. It’s hot everywhere.”

Advertisement

Aside from the effects of the bill—the opinions are just as polarized among physicians as they are among politicians and patients—the debate over the reform consumes most of what little spare time Peterson and his colleagues have.

“A lot of it is time wasted because we’re all very busy just trying to do our jobs. In other words, I’m wasting time trying to understand and implement something that doesn’t make sense,” says Dr. Tommy Hansbrough, an ear, nose and throat surgeon who is a partner in the physician-owned Surgical Specialty Center. “This bill is an overhaul of a way of life.”

It’s not that Hansbrough doesn’t enjoy discussing ways to improve health care; indeed, he acknowledges improvements are sorely needed in some areas, and he has numerous suggestions. Hansbrough just wishes the politicians responsible for the reform had asked him and his colleagues as many questions while putting the bill together as employees and patients now are asking.

“The physicians were never brought in to help solve this problem, and that’s what is most distressing about it,” Hansbrough says. “I feel like the integrity of my profession is being eroded by people who don’t know anything about medicine except making sure their bottom line is increasing at the expense of my services.”

Hansbrough has been seeing patients for 28 years and has a well-established practice, but he fears the bill jeopardizes his livelihood. Its mandates will have negative consequences for doctors and patients, he says, and some of his colleagues in a recent study by Thomson Reuters and practice management company HCPlexus express the same trepidation.

Almost 3,000 physicians across the U.S. were surveyed between September and December. Seventy-eight percent of the doctors who participated in the study say the bill will have negative consequences for their practices; 58% say the bill will be bad for their patients; and 65% say the quality of health care will deteriorate because of the reform.

Peterson is part of the minority that feels the positive effects of reform will outweigh the negative. He admits being more excited about the changes when they were initially introduced in 2009. Reading the bill for himself and tuning out the political pundits has eased his fears and left him in the middle of the debate, he says, but that doesn’t mean he isn’t taking some precautions as a small-business owner to offset any potential negative consequences.

“With the uncertainty—not only with health care reform, but also the possible declines in Medicare reimbursements—we’re not going to hire, even though I could probably go around this office and find jobs for five extra people,” Peterson says, adding that about 20% of his patients rely on Medicare. “We also didn’t do any raises this year. We just couldn’t.”

For other doctors, the uncertainty is causing them to take more drastic measures. Some are completely rethinking their careers and practice models, says Louisiana State Medical Society President Dr. Pat Breaux, who is a cardiologist at Ochsner Medical Center in New Orleans. A trend of private practice physicians selling out to hospitals is emerging, he says, because they don’t want to deal with the effects of the bill.

“They’re just throwing up their hands in the face of all this red tape. They just want to practice,” Breaux says. “In my 35 years of practice, I have never seen as much change in our profession or threat to the health care system. I’ve also never seen patients as engaged in the discussion as they are now.”

There are even doctors who are walking away from the profession altogether, Hansbrough says, because of the uncertainty and anxiety created by the reform.

“Some of my colleagues who have been practicing as long as I have and have saved up enough money to retire, they’re just quitting because they don’t want to deal with the bureaucracy,” he says. “These are doctors who are really in the prime of their careers, and they’re quitting five or 10 years before they should or could.”

Hansbrough and Peterson have differing opinions on the effects of reform, but they have much more in common. Among their commonalities, perhaps most important is a continued commitment to their patients. Neither is thinking about selling their physician-owned practices or leaving the profession early.

“Medicine is a childhood dream that came true for me. I’ve put a lot of time, effort and training into becoming an expert at what I do, and I still want to be the best ear, nose and throat doctor that I can be,” says Hansbrough, estimating his income has decreased 20% over the past two decades and his patient load has increased by 40%.

The future of the reform bill remains unclear, as Republicans continue to push to repeal the bill or, at the very least, modify its mandates. Likewise, it doesn’t look as if doctors are going to be any less inundated with questions or concerns about reform anytime soon.

“The pressure on physicians right now is extraordinary and unlike anything they’ve ever experienced before,” Breaux says. “I don’t see the turmoil ending in the foreseeable future because, candidly, I see no clear-cut solutions on the horizon.”

Discussion (0)

From Our Partners

Daily Report Poll

ASK AI

Ask anything about Baton Rouge business