Tuition is not a tax, it’s a choice

Author Profile Image
Sign up for the free Daily Report email – local news about the people, companies and issues that impact business impact business in Baton Rouge and beyond.

I wonder … If they increased the interest rate on a loan at the bank where State Sen. Lydia Jackson works, would she consider that a tax? Or would it just be a reflection of the market and result of increased costs? Of course, in our free enterprise system, the customer can then decide whether the higher rate is acceptable and worth it, or they can change banks. They have a choice. So do students.

The senator seems to think that if a public college or university experiences increased costs [as they provide a superior product] and new market conditions, and then changes their tuition upward, that is a tax on students. This despite the fact that students have a choice not to pay it, if they do not see the value, and instead find another provider for their education.

I also wonder if the president of Sen. Jackson’s bank would be willing to personally pay higher taxes and have the bank pay more as well? That is the senator’s solution.

Advertisement

In response to Gov. Bobby Jindal’s plan for higher education released last week, Sen. Jackson, D-Shreveport, believes the state should consider tax increases instead of increasing tuition. She said, “It seems odd to me that we want to tax students’ aspirations, but we will not look at the people who are producers in our economy.”

First, I’d like to point out that most of those producers are college grads who paid their own way through college, took student loans or had parents who sacrificed and saved to send them. There was no TOPS for the boomers. So now she thinks it’s fair to tax these “producers,” to make them pay again so current students can go to college. Is this some prank, Sen. Jackson?

Those college grads who are now “producing” are reaping the fruits of their labor. They have sowed, and now they reap. [A good lesson for any college student.] But just like going to see a movie, you must first buy a ticket. Not pay a tax, get a ticket. The same is true for getting on the train of success. One must first buy a ticket to college to get a seat. It’s a ticket, not a tax. You are free to buy one or not—just like at the movies.

Let me also share with Jackson the definition of a tax, which is “a charge usually of money imposed by legislative or other public authority upon persons or property for public purposes.”

In contrast to that, the definition of tuition is “the payment for instruction, especially in colleges or universities.”

One can clearly see that a tax is “imposed” upon people and used for “public purposes.” No one is forcing tuition upon a student—they can refuse and choose to go elsewhere. And a student’s college education is not a public purpose; while educated workers are certainly an asset for a community, the main beneficiary is the student. [And they are also free to take that state subsidized degree and head out of state for a higher-paying job. In that case there is no public benefit, just a public expense.]

Just like $1 is the price for a hamburger at McDonald’s, tuition, at whatever level, is the cost for knowledge at a college or university. Sen. Jackson must know you can’t buy a steak for $1, but the difference in the higher price for steak is not a “tax,” but instead, what the provider and the marketplace agree is the difference in value. That’s the way our free market works. And it is the greatest system on Earth.

So as the debate begins about what authority or freedom our colleges and universities should be given, let me point out that Louisiana students currently pay the lowest in-state tuition in the South. As a taxpayer, I am not interested in paying any more to subsidize someone’s college education. If Jackson and her colleagues in the Legislature imposed that on me, that would be a TAX. Someone paying for a service or product they choose to receive is called the cost or price—NOT A TAX. And prices go up, just like interest rates at banks on loans.

Our state has a generous TOPS program to cover tuition costs for good students. There are also scholarships, Pell grants and student loans available to make college possible. Not to mention part-time jobs.

I am sure Jackson knows in recent years, every time tuition was increased, TOPS would be increased and cover the difference. But then that would mean the “new tax” in tuition was being paid by the state, and government doesn’t pay taxes. No, as long as government is paying the tab it is not a “tax” but just another program or entitlement—and I guess Jackson is OK with that. Maybe we should let people pay a little of the cost for those things government provides, and they might value them more. They could even become responsible. Now there’s an idea. [I’ll share some stories I heard in a future column.]

There are many parts to Jindal’s agenda for higher education this session, and they will bring a welcome change to the landscape for the future. One of those is a single board of governance, which Jindal says is needed to provide “a highly coordinated system with a laser-like focus on outcomes.” It can also end turf battles and help decisions be made more quickly. Right now, we have too many chiefs.

LSU Chancellor Mike Martin likes the governor’s plan. He says, “We are especially pleased with Governor Jindal’s proposals to grant greater flexibility and autonomy to universities in exchange for improved performance. Flexibilities in the areas the governor mentioned—human resources, procurement, facility services and capital projects, and more—would enable LSU to save the state tens of millions of dollars over the next five years. These operational flexibilities would give LSU the ability to be more entrepreneurial and find more efficient, cost-effective ways of operating.”

Less is better

Rep. M.J. “Mert” Smiley is consistent—and I like it. Year after year he brings bills to eliminate boards and commissions that have little purpose. In the past seven years, Smiley helped abolish more than 100 boards and commissions, and he’s going for seven more this session. Smiley says he wants them to justify their existence. He says then they could consider a merger, their duties being turned over to a department of state government, or elimination. Makes too much sense.

Now we are seeing some similar action locally. Metro Council member “Smokie” Bourgeois wants to abolish the EBR Alcoholic Beverage Control Board. He says the administrator can do the job and the board is unnecessary. From what I have seen and heard I think the public may like this idea. I do. And “Smokie” can become the “Smiley” of local government and start looking at other boards next. I say, the less of government, the better.

Is anyone home?

If politicians wonder why their profession has a bad reputation, they just need to read the story in The Advocate last week on the challenge to school board member Randy Lamana, and whether he has a legal domicile in District 11. Lamana says he has his trailer in place on a lot and moved his voter registration—but he did not have his homestead exemption moved until after he took the oath of office in January.

A voter in the district, Al Walker, is challenging Lamana and says he watched Lamana’s house over a 10-day period and that he lived at his old house and not in the trailer. So why is Lamana playing these games? Why be sneaky? Is this the kind of member we want on the school board looking after our children?

I made it clear in the election last year, Lamana should go. But District 11 made their choice. And voters there just might find themselves having to choose again. The problem is, all of us will have to pay if that special election is required because of Lamana’s shenanigans. I say we just tell them to send the bill to Randy Lamana—if they can figure out where he lives.

Discussion (0)

From Our Partners

Daily Report Poll

ASK AI

Ask anything about Baton Rouge business