This past December, the Board of Elementary and Secondary Education made some significant progress for education reform in Louisiana. The highlights included adoption of Gov. Bobby Jindal’s significant reform bill that was passed by the Legislature, calling for the use of letter grades for school performance so parents understand clearly the situation at their school. An attempt had been made by the status quo to “inflate” the grades and bump them for “progress,” but that was defeated.
In addition, 11 new charters were approved from Lake Charles to New Orleans, including Louisiana’s first two virtual charters. And the Recovery School District schools and students in New Orleans were protected.
BESE member Chas Roemer fought the superintendents’ recommendation to inflate school grades and proposed a plan to give each school the grade it deserves, so parents would have an accurate assessment. And the school must also divulge what percentage of its students are below grade level. Roemer said, “It is not meant to be a criticism or a slap in the face. It is an honest assessment of where do we stand.”
It was disheartening to read the comments of some superintendents recently in The Advocate. One said, “I think sometimes we want to grow things almost too fast.” Are they kidding? We move too slow when it comes to change in Louisiana.
I do commend one superintendent in West Baton Rouge and his attitude. He predicted the new system will have the same positive result it had in Florida over the past 10 years. David Corona said, “We will have shown even more improvement than we have in the past 10 years. Once somebody places the bar, man figures out how to get over it.”
I have been involved in school reform for more than 15 years in Louisiana. During the past three, momentum has been building. That’s a ray of hope for thousands of children in our public schools. Kudos to Jindal, Supt. Paul Pastorek, Roemer, Rep. Steve Carter, the rest of the BESE board and the Legislature for their vision, courage and leadership on these critical issues. Don’t stop now.
Higher ed needs reform too
Some people would just prefer things never change. It’s easier to do it the way we’ve always done it before. But change is inevitable. And that is especially true of higher education in Louisiana, considering the budget issues we face. Unfortunately, it is in crisis, when our backs are against the wall, that Louisianans finally make the tough decisions. Dealing with our system of higher education is one of those.
Maybe it’s time we considered free market principles and got the Legislature and politics out of the business of setting tuition. Maybe it’s time we let the quality of the product, supply and demand, and competition determine the price. Parents and students can choose for themselves what they value, where they want to go and how much they’re willing to pay. Give the universities and their “customers” that freedom. It will work, just like it works in your industry. Let the market reward or punish the providers. And that freedom should also extend to purchasing and pension funds. Free the universities from the red tape and bureaucracy. Jindal refers to this as La. GRAD 2.0.
As for governance of higher education, we should go to a single board and demand its members deal with the duplication of programs in a major way—and examine closure or mergers of institutions. Promote more focus on excellence in specific areas for each college. Every college can’t be all things to all people. Enough with the bickering and back-stabbing among the current four boards. Settle it with one board—and let them deal with the task until they get it done.
Wish list for Legislature
In addition to a single board of higher education, more free market ideas for our universities and continued school choice reforms, I do have a couple of other “wishes” on my list for this year’s legislative session.
1) No new taxes. I am sure our legislators (and especially the new Republican majority) were paying attention on Nov. 2. I think they saw that Congress got voters’ message, as indicated by the extension of the Bush tax cuts. Take heed leges—don’t think of sticking your hand in our pockets.
2) Deal with Civil Service. Everyone wants to cut the number of state jobs, but it’s not easy due to an archaic and out-dated system: Civil Service. It’s an old model, just like unions. Make drastic changes or eliminate it. It breeds mediocrity and inefficiency and kills motivation.
