Oil and gas companies are asking a federal appeals court to reconsider its previous decision that parish lawsuits alleging damage of coastal wetlands should be heard in state court.
In August, a three-judge panel of the New Orleans-based U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit unanimously rejected the companies’ argument that the case belongs in federal court. The defendants are asking the panel and the court as a whole to review that decision, The Center Square reports.Â
In 2013, local governments in Louisiana’s coastal region filed lawsuits against more than 200 oil and gas companies, seeking compensation for damage they say the companies caused to the region’s wetlands. The companies say they followed their permits and the law as it stood at the time.
The Fifth Circuit panel’s ruling last month only applied directly to lawsuits by Plaquemines and Cameron parishes, though it could have broader implications given the similarities shared by the various lawsuits, experts say. The decision focused on an expert report Plaquemines Parish produced in 2018 that notes some of the alleged damage dates back to World War II.
At the time, the companies argue, they were under strict wartime regulation and essentially were acting as agents of the federal government. That raises a federal issue, which means the cases should be heard in federal court, they say.
But the three judges, all nominated by President Donald Trump, say the companies didn’t raise the issue in time. They said the ties to wartime activities cited in the 2018 report already were established in earlier evidence, and the defendants missed their window to ask for a removal on that basis. Read the full story.Â
