Greg Mitchell grew up across the street from the North Wastewater Treatment Plant, and he still lives there today. He can remember when the plant was a smaller pump station, buffered from his home by a wooded area and a playground that he enjoyed as a child.
The playground is gone now. The plant grew along with the city, he says, to the point that he feels like it’s on top of him. The smell of chemicals and human waste often is overwhelming, he says, causing nausea and aggravating residents’ allergies and breathing conditions.
“This is an environmental disaster for this community,” Mitchell says.
The facility is at the center of a lawsuit filed a year ago by the Louisiana Environmental Action Network against East Baton Rouge. All three parish wastewater plants are in violation of their permits, LEAN says, but the northern plant receives the most attention from the citizens group.
Regardless of how the suit is resolved, Mitchell’s issues likely won’t be; he wants the city to buy him and his neighbors out. But the lawsuit could cost East Baton Rouge more than $2 million, on top of the $1 billion-plus it’s already spending to fix its outdated sewer system. As part of the city-parish’s overhaul of the system, it plans to close the Central plant on River Road and redirect the flow to the South plant on Gardere Lane.
In 2001, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and Louisiana Department of Environmental Quality sued the city-parish, alleging its wastewater treatment plants were violating the federal Clean Water Act. The parties negotiated a consent decree in 2002, which was modified in 2008, requiring the parish to bring itself into compliance by Jan. 15, 2015, according to court documents.
LEAN Executive Director Marylee Orr says the suit was triggered when a representative spotted discharges coming from the northern plant into the Mississippi River. He finally took a sample, and “the fecal coliform count was too numerous to count,” she says. As required by law, LEAN gave East Baton Rouge a notice of intent well before filing suit, but it didn’t receive a response.
“We have not had any communication with East Baton Rouge at all about this,” Orr says. “We thought for sure that the mayor or someone from his staff would approach us.”
Orr says the parish is violating both the Clean Water Act and the consent decree.
The city-parish, for its part, argues the consent decree essentially renders LEAN’s lawsuit moot. Bob Abbott, an assistant parish attorney who has been working on this case, says LEAN’s right of action comes under the same law that allows the Environmental Protection Agency to enforce the Clean Water Act. If a citizen or group believes the EPA isn’t actively prosecuting violations, they have to give the agency 90 days’ notice. If the agency still doesn’t act, the group can file suit.
The parish’s position is that the EPA is taking action through the consent decree. In fact, Abbott says, LEAN is receiving its information from the violations the parish self-reports to the EPA under the terms of that decree. The EPA tallies the fines, but it holds off on requiring payment. The agency is cutting the parish some slack, with the understanding that everyone is diligently working to fix the problems.
“If we complete the consent decree, the hope is they don’t then assess millions of dollars’ worth of fines,” Abbott says. “You can’t correct things overnight.”
The city-parish already has paid $945,500 in penalties, he says, and has totaled more than $1.6 million in stipulated penalties that could be waived if the city meets the deadline for finishing the sewer upgrades. He says LEAN and its attorneys at the Tulane Environmental Law Clinic are trying to assess the same fines.
“Tulane gets attorney fees out of it if they are successful,” Abbott says.
The civil penalty would be paid to the U.S. Treasury.
The EPA weighed in on the city’s side of this issue shortly after the suit was filed in March 2010. Scott McDonald, who handles water enforcement legal issues at the agency’s regional office in Dallas, sent a letter to Adam Babich, director of Tulane’s law clinic, and LEAN, saying the suit was barred under the Clean Water Act. Abbott says the EPA’s attorneys considered filing an amicus brief with the court before they became too busy with the Deepwater Horizon oil spill.
But in a follow-up letter days later that withdrew the original letter, McDonald backtracks a little. He doesn’t take back his interpretation of the law, except to say that only the proper U.S. district court, not the EPA, has the authority to determine a citizen’s standing to sue.
LEAN realizes the sewage plants are subject to a consent decree, but says the city-parish is violating both the plants’ permits and the decree itself. The permit for the infamous north facility, for example, was issued after the original consent decree, Babich says.
“The consent decree didn’t change the permit,” he says. “And frankly, any argument that complying with the consent decree should be good enough pretty much falls apart when you realize they haven’t been complying with the consent decree, either.”
LEAN’s complaint details a number of permit violations relating to two issues: the amount of solids in the wastewater, and high levels of biochemical oxygen demand, which Babich says can be an indicator of bacteria like fecal coliform.
The consent decree also dictates interim limits the city is supposed to follow until it can meet the national standards, Babich says, and those interim limits also are being violated.
If the 2002 consent decree means the parish doesn’t have to comply with the law until 2015, as Babich says Baton Rouge’s interpretation of the law would dictate, then a child born in 2002 in an affected community would lack the protection of the Clean Water Act for the first 13 years of his life.
LEAN is asking for civil penalties of up to $37,500 per violation per day, plus attorney fees and litigation costs. The parish attorney’s office has filed a motion to dismiss. A hearing is scheduled for March 16 before U.S. Circuit Judge Brian Jackson.
