Cowardice and courage
To the publisher:
One of the most offensive things in politics is when someone pushes a questionable idea and then tries to shield it from legitimate criticism by claiming, “This idea should be above politics.” This describes Gov. Bobby Jindal’s proposal to merge Southern University in New Orleans with the University of New Orleans [“Publisher’s View,” March 22]. Under the guise of reform, Jindal rammed this proposal through a deeply divided Louisiana Board of Regents. However, every aspect of the governor’s conduct with respect to this issue smacks of the very politics that Jindal claims to disavow.
First, the oft-repeated 8% graduation rate at SUNO is misleading. Graduation rates measure in specific time increments [most frequently in six-year intervals]; consequently, if some students take longer than six years to graduate, the institution is penalized by the measure. Fifty-five percent of SUNO’s student body is comprised of people 25 years or older; it has the largest population of nontraditional students of any four-year institution in the state.
Students in this group almost invariably work full-time or part-time and also have children to rear. As a consequence, these students are necessarily going to be part-time. Consequently, students who enroll in classes at this pace simply take longer to graduate than the traditional 18- to 22-year-old student population.
In addition, many students within this demographic are not working toward a degree at all. Rather, they are taking courses to acquire or enhance their knowledge or skills [in some cases, to earn promotions or to qualify for new positions]. In other contexts, this would be lauded as workforce development, of which this governor claims to be a big supporter. Such students, however, count against the institution when calculating six-year graduation rates because they do not earn degrees per se.
In summary, it can be very misleading to simply quote the 8% graduation figure without considering what that number means and why it exists. Moreover, if numbers are all that matter, LSU-Alexandria has a 4% graduation rate. Why isn’t Jindal going after LSU-A? Delgado Community College, an institution he claims is growing by leaps and bounds and needs more facilities, has a 2.1% graduation rate, according to the study relied upon by the Regents to justify merging SUNO and UNO. Now who’s playing politics.
Demogoguing about college graduation rates while ignoring the underlying problems in the pre-K-12 educational pipeline may be good politics for the governor, but it is not leadership. Its real purpose is to justify draconian, ill-advised cuts to higher education budgets that jeopardize the state’s economic competitiveness in the long run.
Jindal is more interested in looking like a reformer than he is in doing the hard work it takes to actually move the state forward. Taking on a constituency the governor knows is not likely to vote for him anyway is not visionary. Rather, it is political cowardice masquerading as courage.
Albert L. Samuels, Assistant professor, Department of Political Science, Southern University
To the publisher:
This issue might be about color, but it’s not about black, it’s about green.
By being an HBCU, SUNO has been afforded special grant and funding privileges over the years. We still have Grambling State, Southern and Xavier as HBCUs in Louisiana. If the economics of SUNO and UNO had been solid, this strategy would not even be on the table.
If the economy continues to tumble, it would not be surprising to see other underperforming universities go this route as well. If you want equal justice, campaign for all underperforming universities to be handled at the same time.
Ultimately, Internet education makes obtaining a college degree virtually available from anywhere. We should dramatically restructure our systems to compete in this new education model. Many colleges are already going Internet-based, and we are behind this curve by 20 years.
Submitted online by fulldisclosure
To the publisher:
Has it ever occurred to anyone that Southern University and Grambling State University are the last remaining vestiges of Jim Crow? In reality, why were the two universities started? To provide educational opportunities for blacks while keeping them out of LSU and other white universities.
All of the universities in the state were integrated years ago except for Southern and Grambling. This has been acceptable only because both schools were run by blacks. Educational results were not important and could not be questioned.
It’s well past time the status quo was changed. SUNO is next door to UNO. Grambling is just down the road from Louisiana Tech. Baton Rouge has LSU and Baton Rouge Community College.
David Miller, Baton Rouge
Studying contradictions
To the editor:
Your editorial assumes the questions were asked to answer the analysis you make, which I imagine they were not. You need to analyze how the questions were asked and not make such generalizations from very specific questions [“Random Thoughts,” March 22]. Doing so is what we in the legal world call a tremendous leap of faith without support.
The business community complains that finding a skilled workforce is a problem, not because the higher education system is poor, but because so many in our state do not enter the higher education system and do not have the basic competency skills from their K-12 years, or didn’t even complete their K-12 years.
A generalized question about whether the higher education system in Louisiana is adequate, good or excellent is too broad of a question. Included in the higher education system is LSU, our flagship university that has catapulted to national rankings through much hard work and funding. There are other higher education institutions lumped into the overly broad question.
What people actually believe is not clear from the responses; it’s a result of the poor questions asked in the survey without opportunity for explanation.
Submitted online by jenntmorris
To the editor:
It is a legacy of Louisiana’s populist past that so many want the benefits [state jobs, a relatively inexpensive education, etc.], while wanting others to pay the costs. That same legacy is the main reason the state has suffered retarded economic development. It will take a lot of political will to change the culture.
Submitted online by jeffsadow
A bright future
To the editor:
It is companies like St. James Technologies that make the future economy of Baton Rouge so bright: a spinoff of a larger company that has found a way to commercialize technology is a great success for the Baton Rouge area [“Harboring opportunities,” March 22]. Hopefully, successes of companies like St. James will give other companies the courage to be innovators. We cannot have too many Matthew Magnusons in Baton Rouge if we truly hope to be the “Creative Capital of the South.”
Submitted online by lsugolfer
