The zip-a-dee-doo-dah days of the indentured servant model of college athletics—the one where everyone gets rich except the young men and women putting their bodies at risk—are all but over.
Amidst Supreme Court rulings and the NCAA backing down on name, image and likeness, a more equitable—and businesslike—age is dawning at LSU and everywhere else where the tail of athletics tends to wag the university dog, Business Report Executive Editor J.R. Ball writes in a new opinion piece. Smashed into oblivion is the notion that the only thing amateur in the $8.5 billion enterprise known as Division I athletics are the athletes who double as students.
Ther most immediate impact comes courtesy of legislatures across the country, including here in Louisiana, and finally a backed-in-the-corner NCAA that sets free the name, image and likeness (NIL) of college athletes.
That means a star quarterback can go into business with a video game maker or trading card company. It means that volleyball player with 80,000 social media followers can make a deal to promote products on her channel. It means that a baseball player can become a pitchman for a business near you.
Yet a unanimous Supreme Court earlier in June struck the real blow for economic freedom. Both the liberal and conservative justices joined forces to annihilate the plantation mentality of college athletics, declaring the NCAA is violating antitrust law by placing limits on academic-related benefits a school like LSU can provide to athletes donning the purple and gold.
Though the decision in NCAA v. Alston was on a pretty narrow issue, Justice Brett M. Kavanaugh provided the drop-the-mike moment, writing this in a concurrence to the decision: “The NCAA couches its arguments for not paying student athletes in innocuous labels. But the labels cannot disguise the reality: The NCAA’s business model would be flatly illegal in almost any other industry in America.”
That’s some harsh truth.
How many lawyers are lining up to file the first in what will be a barrage of litigation demanding compensation for college athletes beyond education-related expenses? And if what Kavanaugh wrote didn’t do it, this will: “Put simply, this suit involves admitted horizontal price fixing in a market where the defendants (the NCAA) exercise market control,” wrote Justice Neil M. Gorsuch in the majority opinion.
The bottom line, writes Ball: Over are the days when everyone involved in this sham system—coaches, athletic directors, university presidents, conference officials, NCAA pooh-bahs and television network executives—gets rich off the semi-free labor of the college athlete workforce.
Read Ball’s full column from the latest edition of Daily Report. Send comments to editor@businessreport.com.
