Editors note: This column has been updated since original publication.
You knew it wouldn’t be long after Gov. Bobby Jindal asked the Board of Regents to study the idea of merging Southern University at New Orleans with the University of New Orleans that the word “race” would enter the fray. But the “R” word that we all should be using is “results.” If you look at SUNO’s 5% graduation rate over a six-year period, and its enrollment of just over 3,000 students, and the fact it’s the lowest-ranked university in the state, there is no question that SUNO is the top candidate for closure or merger. There is no defense, and taxpayers should not have to fund it. It should have never re-opened after Katrina.
UNO, which is just two blocks away, has capacity and better results [21% graduation rate]. But Jindal is not trying to make the LSU System happy; he proposes taking the newly merged school and putting it under the ULL system. [Instead of taking one from this system and one from that, and giving them both to another system, in this session we need to just put all the universities under a single governance board that can make all the major decisions. One state, one board, one system.]
Members of the Louisiana Legislative Black Caucus have come out firing. “The battle is on,” said Rep. Austin Badon, who is on the staff of SUNO. Rep. Charmaine Staies, a SUNO graduate, is opposed and said SUNO and the Southern System have been the targets of “racially motivated” attacks for years. Then she went on to make excuses for the low graduation rate and asked for more time—an old stall tactic.
This week, Randolph Scott, president of the SUNO Alumni Association, said, “Southern University was not developed to graduate people. It was developed for poor and poorly prepared people … the opportunity to get a higher education. We (SUNO) don’t have to graduate anyone.” The remarks were made prior to a press conference held by SUNO’s chancellor, the Southern System president and the chairman of the Southern System Board of Supervisors to address the claims about enrollment and graduation rates. A comment so ridiculous from one of the few who did graduate from SUNO is just more evidence why SUNO should not remain open. One could wonder if SUNO really was created to generate graduates—or just to generate jobs.
Rep. Pat Smith, head of the caucus, went on TV and said the proposal is “bad timing.” Right, like there would be a good time to propose this.
No, it is the right time. Budget deficits require priorities, and if we just said “cut the lowest producers, white or black,” it would still be SUNO. In the state’s accountability program for K-12, they don’t take over the top producers, they take those failing schools away from school boards—and SUNO is failing badly.
Smith said the caucus was suspicious and had no input. She said the Southern System was working on a plan for SUNO. Really? Just now working on a plan? Wasn’t SUNO closed after Katrina? So, when it re-opened, they didn’t have a plan? This August will be six years since Katrina, and Southern is just now working on a plan for SUNO? Sorry, that’s just another delay tactic.
Smith didn’t want to say that this was “racial,” but noted they are “watching this diversity issue closely.” Well, good. Maybe they should have been watching SUNO’s graduation rate closely over these last 20 years and we might not be discussing the merger at all.
Jindal deserves kudos for his courage to take on this issue and the “politically correct” crowd. He gets it, as shown when he said, “We need to do what is best for the students. This can’t be driven by politics. You’ll hear all kinds of excuses.”
Legislators need to get the information from Regents and make tough decisions now. Jindal added, “What we do not need to do is continue to defer this, continue to discuss this ad nauseam.”
Decision time is coming, and one’s vote in the Legislature should be based on results, not race. And that applies to the members of the Black Caucus, too—unless, of course, this is “racial.”
The costs of crime
Last week it was announced that Louisiana was selected for a new partnership with The Pew Center on the States’ Public Safety Performance Project, which will fund research on Louisiana’s criminal justice system to develop a set of policies to reform the system.
Jindal said, “With this partnership we’ll have a better understanding of what policies work, and which ones won’t so we can do an even better job of decreasing recidivism in Louisiana.”
Adam Gelb of the Pew Center said, “Policy makers across the country are recognizing that prisons, just like any government spending program, need to be put to the cost-benefit test to make sure taxpayers are getting the best possible public safety return on their dollars. There is now a strong commitment from Louisiana’s top leaders to take a hard look at the numbers here, and we are confident this bipartisan, data-driven effort will produce a plan that improves public safety while lowering costs.”
In 2009, Louisiana had the highest rate of incarceration in the United States: 881 prisoners per 100,000 residents. The U.S. national average was 502, and Mississippi was second at a rate of 702 per 100,000 residents. A total of 95% of Louisiana offenders entering the state’s criminal justice system will return to our communities. The state’s overall five-year recidivism rate is about 48%.
We are dealing with our own crime issues in Baton Rouge—and will have to address the issue and costs of new prison space and a juvenile jail this fall.
National school choice week
We can actually celebrate this week in Louisiana because there is growing evidence of “choice” for parents and students. Having a governor who is committed to students and parents, instead of to the teachers unions and protecting jobs for adults, has made a huge difference.
We now have 90 charter schools operating in Louisiana—and New Orleans is the only city in America with a majority of students in charter schools. In fact, last week, the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools ranked Louisiana as one of the top 10 states [No. 9] with strong charter school legislation. [Kathy Riedlinger, CEO of Lusher Charter in New Orleans, gave high praise to the Louisiana Association of Public Charter Schools, saying, “LAPCS’s director, Caroline Roemer-Shirley, brings the diverse opinions and needs of charter schools in this state together and organizes us into a unified voice.” She deserves the praise.]
We also are fortunate to have 1,697 students in New Orleans who participate in a scholarship [or voucher] program and can escape their failing public school and go to the school of their choice—including private. And we now have two virtual charter schools approved to allow teaching with technology and distance learning.
There is still more we can do in the future to increase choices for more parents. In fact, I was at the LABI luncheon recently when Jindal asked for support to help pass a new bill fashioned after a Florida law known as the “Charter-Schools-in-the-Workplace Initiative,” which 14 other states have introduced.
Businesses can partner with a charter school and provide a facility or land and other support, and then have a percentage of seats in the school allocated for children of their employees. Jindal said, “This legislation is a win-win for the students and the businesses. We can and must provide every student in Louisiana with a quality education. We have more work to do to make sure no student is trapped in a failing school.”
I noticed the idea has drawn support in editorials in the Alexandria Town Talk and the Lafayette Advertiser.
There is still the choice of going to a public [or government-run] school, a category which includes some top-notch magnet schools. And competition with the “new options” above will make them all better—or else. If they can’t attract parents and students with the quality of their product and deliver results, then why should they be open? Businesses with an inferior product in the marketplace seldom survive. Why should our tax-funded schools be any different? Deliver results or let the money go to someone else who can. And Jindal believes the best people to decide where a child can flourish are the parents and the child—not the government. That is choice, and we are finally getting a real taste of it in Louisiana. Now that’s something to celebrate.
