Getting our priorities straight

Author Profile Image
Sign up for the free Daily Report email – local news about the people, companies and issues that impact business impact business in Baton Rouge and beyond.

The chicken farmers want their processing plant saved. Artists are holding jazz funerals to protest funding cuts. Local governments are scrambling for scraps of road construction money. University presidents and chancellors are bracing for Armageddon.

With the state facing a $2 billion budget deficit, anyone receiving even a dollar of taxpayer cash is fighting to protect their financial turf. Everyone acknowledges budget cuts are coming; they just don’t want it to be their budget that’s sliced.

State residents are seemingly in touch with that emotion. A plurality of people [48%] want Gov. Jindal and the Legislature to solve the fiscal crisis with budget cuts only, according to LSU’s Public Policy Research Lab and its Spring 2009 Louisiana Survey. Interesting is that the number soars to 60.6% if the respondent will feel no negative impact from cuts. If someone has a dog in the hunt, the number drops to 45.8%.

Advertisement

What does all this mean? To borrow a phrase from Russell Long: Don’t cut you, don’t cut me, cut that guy behind the tree.

Which brings us to the following scenario: Jindal says he will not raise taxes by a single penny and would actually love to hack a business tax or two; legislators aren’t sure what to do—some are proposing sin taxes, some want to overhaul the property tax homestead exemption, most want to protect their pet projects and all are being bombarded by pleas for mercy from those facing the budget ax; and LED Secretary Stephen Moret is scrambling to spend his $414 million economic development megafund on anything and everything [except higher education] before legislators can get their hands on it.

Can you imagine what the state would be facing if, as government officials love to trumpet, Louisiana wasn’t creating new jobs and staying one step ahead of the national recession? Then again, had state government cut its dependence on oil and gas revenues—instead of going on a tax-cutting frenzy—when state coffers were overflowing with revenue, then the picture today wouldn’t be so bleak. But, hey, since when has long-term planning ever trumped our desire for instant gratification?

So what’s a state government to do when it’s $2 billion short, won’t raise taxes and everyone dependent upon government funds is claiming their needs are sacred?

The answer is a little something I—and David Osborne, of Reinventing Government fame—like to call “priority-based budgeting.”

My model is simple. K-12 public education, health care, higher education [including community and technical colleges] and building a knowledge-based economy become state government’s top four priorities. Before anything else tied to state government sees a single penny, these four get their money—all of it.

If you like, create a tier of secondary priorities for things like roads and other infrastructure. Anything else involving taxpayer money is then rated based on its impact or relationship to the state’s core, or foundational, priorities. Who does the rating? A nonpartisan commission made up of individuals appointed by the governor, the Legislature and organizations related to these core priorities (universities, community colleges, hospitals, school systems, and chambers, etc.) By the way, earmarks and slush funds are wiped from the face of the state.

What about a program or organization that provides services to the poor? Well, depending on what the program actually does and its effectiveness [and depending on whether or not the private sector can better address the matter], it would score high since poverty negatively impacts all four of Louisiana’s core priorities.

Culture and the arts? Quality of life is clearly important in the quest to build a knowledge-based economy and decreasingly so for public education, higher education and health care.

Saving a chicken plant in Farmerville? Very important to the 1,300 people who will lose their jobs, but the state getting into the chicken business isn’t so important to its foundational interests.

Budget decisions are made based on the state’s core interests, not emotion or political influence. Every year the state wipes the budget clean and each state agency and program must produce data tracking the efficiency and effectiveness of its previous fiscal year dollars while justifying its request for future money.

What are the odds of adopting an idea that’s already widely used in the private sector? Slim. What fun is it if you remove the politics from government?

Discussion (0)

From Our Partners

Daily Report Poll

ASK AI

Ask anything about Baton Rouge business