Fayard slams exclusion from US Senate forum as ‘good ol’ boy cronyism’

Author Profile Image
Sign up for the free Daily Report email – local news about the people, companies and issues that impact business impact business in Baton Rouge and beyond.

New Orleans businesswoman Caroline Fayard is calling the National Federation of Independent Business’ decision to exclude her from its U.S. Senate candidate forum today “undemocratic, insulting” and says “it smacks of insider, good ol’ boy cronyism.”

The NFIB, along with the Louisiana Restaurant Association and Louisiana Retailers Association, is hosting four candidates for Sen. David Vitter’s seat—state Treasurer John Kennedy, Public Service Commissioner Foster Campbell, and U.S. Reps. Charles Boustany and John Fleming—in a forum on business issues taking place today at Ruffino’s De La Ronde Hall, 320 3rd St. Kennedy, Boustany and Fleming are Republicans, while Campbell is a Democrat, like Fayard.

“I am especially disappointed, particularly as the only businesswoman in the race, that these organizations would go out of their way to actively exclude me, as well as others, based on specious math and arbitrary criteria,” Fayard says in a statement.

Advertisement

She adds that she imagines the NFIB’s female and minority members do not “wish to hear exclusively from four male politicians who have been drawing comfortable taxpayer salaries while we have been fighting through the worst economy since the Great Depression.”

Fayard is not the only candidate not invited to the forum.

Dawn Starns, NFIB’s state director, tells Daily Report that the firm used data from a statewide poll conducted on June 1 by Bernie Pinsonat of the nonpartisan firm Southern Media and Opinion Research to decide which candidates to include. Candidates needed at least 5% in the poll to be invited to the NFIB forum.

“We wanted to have a really impactful conversation about the issues with our membership,” Starns says, adding that narrowing down the field from the 11 candidates who have filed Federal Election Commission paperwork was the best way to have an intimate, impactful conversation about businesses and small business owners’ needs.

“We just feel that’s the best way to be impactful and the best use of people’s time,” Starns says.

In a statement, Fayard claims Pinsonat’s poll is partisan because it was underwritten by Baton Rouge businessman Lane Grigsby, who has also given $50,000 to Kennedy’s SuperPAC.

Pinsonat says Fayard polled at 4% in his poll, as did another candidate, Rob Maness.

“She just doesn’t have the public recognition because she last ran a few years back, but common sense says she might be one of the stronger candidates,” Pinsonat says, pointing to his May poll in which 58% of respondents did not know who Fayard was.

Pinsonat admits the poll was paid for by Grigsby, but adds the Baton Rouge businessman sponsors a lot of polls. A February poll that was sponsored by subscribers came back with virtually the same numbers.

Pinsonat says he feels that some organizations need to use different criteria other than just polling data when deciding which candidates to include in forums.

“I think her problem ought to be with NFIB,” Pinsonat adds. “She was a candidate a few years back, ran a good race against (former Lt. Gov.) Jay Dardenne and has enough money to qualify.”

Fayard also points to subsequent polls that show her coming in at 9% and 14%.

Starns, however, says the poll where Fayard came in at 14% was paid for by Fayard’s campaign and that NFIB stayed away from polls conducted by the candidates or paid for by their campaigns. She also says she does not know which campaigns Grigsby has given money and that NFIB did not check financial disclosure forms before making its decision.

—Ryan Broussard

Discussion (0)

From Our Partners

Daily Report Poll

ASK AI

Ask anything about Baton Rouge business