What are your expectations of government? Forget the blabbering rhetoric from the nethermost fringes of our political parties. Forget the sound-bite clichés of broad-brush ideals that sound great in theory yet are oh-so-impossible in reality. Forget your tea parties, your coffee parties and your blue dogs.
Strip away the ideology and ponder this: What do you want from government and how much are you willing to pay for these services?
For this discussion, let’s eliminate the role of the federal government, which is gridlocked by the above, slow-moving by design and otherwise occupied selling our country to China.
Besides, it’s at the state and local levels where one really gets a sense for what a person, a community, a city, a parish or a region desires. And it’s in Louisiana’s phallic-shaped Capitol and in city halls across this parish and region where the decisions are made that directly impact your everyday life; decisions decided in your backyard by people who are your neighbors.
Remarkably, ideology—of both the politician and the people he or she represents—tends to vanish once you start talking about topics close to home.
So what is it that you want?
It’s a question far more difficult to answer than it seems—mostly because we’re a community of contradiction. We’ve grown up with a populist heritage but have grown contemptuous of taxes. We don’t want government telling us what we can do with our lives and property but do demand that government tell others what they can do with their lives and property. We don’t especially like government spending tax dollars to enable other constituencies but do like government spending tax dollars to enable our constituency.
Even on a subject with near unanimous agreement—doing something about our horrendous roads and nightmare traffic—there’s no consensus on what that “something” is and, as important, how we will pay for it.
Which brings us back to the essential questions: What do you want from government and how much are you willing to pay for these services?
The seemingly easy answer on the second question is that there’s already enough tax revenue rolling into government coffers and the time has come to stop spending on the things we deem wasteful and focus our dollars on things we treasure. Unfortunately, one man’s waste is another man’s treasure.
How concerned are you about the ballooning unfunded liability of state and local government retirement systems? When should we get around to dealing with a $20 billion—and growing—problem that might bankrupt the state as soon as 2019? How do you want to address the problem? Are you willing to have your community festival lose its annual taxpayer grant? Are you willing to tell your neighbor, who works for city or state government and was planning on retiring after 25 years of work at the age of 50, that he or she can’t start collecting retirement checks until the age of 65?
Does it bother you that not only do we have the worst health care system in America but we also lack the funds to maintain the worst health care system in America? Is health care more important than using tax dollars to, for example, support golf courses, professional sports teams or community centers? Will you support a tax increase dedicated to health care funding?
Are you OK with the fact we are home to one of the worst public school systems in America? Do you care that nearly one of every six residents in this parish lives in poverty? What role does government play in addressing the issue? Nearly one-third, or $9 billion, of this state’s budget is spent on poverty-related programs. Is anyone demanding an audit to measure the effectiveness of this spending or offering alternative solutions?
Baton Rouge is fast replacing New Orleans as the murder capital of this country, and study after study shows we’re a population in fear of crime. What’s not known is what we’re willing to do about it—other than scream for someone to think of something while we huddle in perceived safety behind the gates of our single-entrance subdivisions.
Similar questions can be asked about higher education, roads, sewer systems, drainage canals, libraries, parks, mass transportation, museums and the importance of downtown. And the list goes on and on.
There’s no end to what we’ve come to expect from government.
Yet it’s clear state and local governments can no longer afford to give us everything we’re demanding. Something has got to give.
Once again: What do you want from government and how much are you willing to pay for it?
