If the Tucson shooting was supposed to usher in an era of civility in our politics and public discourse, Mayor Kip Holden apparently did not get the memo.
In a wonderfully moving Jan. 12 speech in Tucson, President Obama called on the nation to abandon myopia, narcissism and monologue and embrace collaboration, unselfishness and dialogue. Exactly two weeks later, an upbeat, yet combative Holden used his State of the Parish speech to proclaim he’s ordained with a mandate of progress and that he—and, ostensibly, we—will attack, ridicule and crush anyone who stands between the mayor and his vision for a better Baton Rouge.
There was no mention of repairing his fractured relationship with numerous Metro Council members. There was no olive branch extended to leaders of Zachary and Central—or to the presidents of neighboring parishes. There was no admission of any personal failure or an ounce of humility.
There was only this: “I’m singularly focused on my commitment to move the city and parish forward. I believe I was elected by you with a mandate to reach for higher goals.”
No doubt, election night returns indicated people love the mayor and the notion of chasing greatness. Unfortunately, this version of “one love” has blinded Holden to this other election night fact: People may like him, but they don’t like his brand of downtown-infused greatness.
To be clear, I happen to agree with much of Holden’s vision for the future of Baton Rouge and the parish. Yet, what I’ve come to accept—and Holden apparently has not—is that a majority of East Baton Rouge residents have a different, only-in-my-backyard [OIMBY] point-of-view. Consequently, the oft-mentioned dream of becoming America’s next great city, like our ridiculously disjointed road system, is an odyssey littered with scores of parochial detours.
Which is where the words civility, conversation and compromise must enter the vernacular.
Government, by design, doesn’t move fast. The people of Baton Rouge, by heritage, don’t accept change readily. For decades, everyone essentially embraced these concepts, living happily in friendly, vanilla, suburban enclaves and willing to take two modest steps forward for every parochial step back.
Then, along comes Holden, who, like so many others in today’s public life, believes only he has ownership of the truth. All of them prefer monologues to dialogues and believe the only victory is one that’s total and absolute.
I know this because I tend to be one of these people. However, I’m a columnist paid to express opinions and spark dialogue without actually having to do anything. Elected officials, on the other hand, must actually do something while representing all of the people who select them to lead.
This narcissistic philosophy, rooted in the advent of every kid getting a trophy, is not the exclusive domain of elected officials. It permeates society, evidenced by the demand for instant gratification, the ready transferal of blame and an unwaveringly partisan approach to politics.
The collision of these self-indulgent ideologies produces angry politicians, even angrier citizens and a tendency to cower in the corner of like-minded thought for validation and self-worth.
Which is why it might be wise for Holden and the rest of us to consider the gumbo.
This south Louisiana original not only traces its roots to a blend of more than seven culinary cultures but, more important, it’s a beloved concoction where you take a little of this, a little of that, and blend it with the right roux and some rice to create edible genius.
In short, gumbo is the ultimate metaphor for civility. It only works if the tastes of all are included; dismiss or over-saturate the contribution of one and the entire dish collapses into a distasteful mess.
Near the end of his speech, Holden made a plea for unity, asking all of us to work together “rather than to let anger and negativity tear us apart. Focus on the positive aspects of our community and find ways to work together to solve our problems.”
Nice words, but they only have meaning if everyone—including Holden—is willing to embrace them.
