Woman’s Hospital CEO Teri Fontenot is a self-described glass-half-full kind of person.
Fontenot acknowledges “there’s some hysteria being promoted” over the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, but she’s encouraged the nation at least is talking about controlling costs and expanding coverage to the uninsured.
“I’m not a 100% supporter of the reform effort,” Fontenot says, noting she’d like to see more accountability imposed on patients. “But I think it has more good parts than bad parts, and I understand that something has to change.”
Many providers expressed a similar mix of wariness and cautious optimism last year, when President Barack Obama signed the bill. The law set guidelines and intent, but the lack of specifics regarding implementation made a lot of people nervous.
Now, almost one year later, new regulations gradually are emerging, but hospitals remain unsure how they fit in. Republicans, meanwhile, are vowing to overturn the law, adding another layer of uncertainty to the issue. The recent repeal measure passed by the House of Representatives likely is going nowhere, but some in Congress say they’ll try to take down the new law piece by piece, cutting off its funding if necessary
How does a hospital CEO run a business at a time like this?
“That’s the environment we’ve lived in for 20 years,” Fontenot says, smiling like someone who’s learned to roll with whatever the latest crisis in health care might be. “It’s a very unstable business to be in.”
One reason Fontenot can smile: The insurance industry is first in line for reform. Hospitals still have time to study the original legislation and the new regulations that are being issued without having to make any big investments to meet those rules.
John Matessino, head of the Louisiana Hospital Association, says he recently returned from Washington, D.C., with the impression that no one there knows how the rules will work, either.
“The only thing certain about health care reform right now is that nothing is certain about health care reform,” he says. “I think there will be changes to the changes.”
Matessino says he doesn’t expect a full repeal. He says local hospitals already are busy dealing with Medicaid funding issues at the state level, to the extent that federal reform almost is in the background. Not that the two issues are totally unrelated; the law could put millions more on Medicaid, which critics say will only put more stress on a system that is co-funded by the federal government and states.
“There are over 150 boards, bureaucracies and commissions called for by this bill, and only a fraction have been implemented,” says U.S. Rep. Bill Cassidy, a Baton Rouge Republican who also is a doctor. “There is no certainty as to where this is going.”
Cassidy issued “Ten Good Reasons for Repeal” in mid-January. His release avoids the rhetoric about a government takeover of health care favored by some of his colleagues, but points out that the word “shall” shows up more than 4,000 times in the law. Cassidy predicts the 997-page bill eventually will be dwarfed by the reams of regulations created to enforce it. The law spells out intent but is light on specifics, which means Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius and the bureaucrats who work under her could end up with a great deal of authority to interpret the law.
So what’s the intent? Experts say Congress is trying to nudge the industry away from the fee-for-service model and toward a more holistic approach that rewards improving patients’ health.
“In the past, we’ve all been rewarded for doing lots of things,” Lane Regional Medical Center CEO Randy Olson says. “Lots of procedures, lots of surgeries, lots of drugs and things like that, without measured outcomes.”
Olson still is studying how his hospital will approach the new law. He says Lane likely will join forces with other providers in the market in what the law calls “accountable care organizations,” which are groups of providers who agree to be accountable for the quality, cost and overall care of at least 5,000 Medicare beneficiaries. Save money on those patients, the government says, and an ACO can share in the savings. There are laws that hinder collaboration, however, which is another issue regulators must sort through.
Under the current system, doctors and hospitals often have conflicting incentives. An insurance company sometimes will deny payment to a hospital when a patient doesn’t meet the company’s criteria for acute care, Olson says, but will still pay a doctor for seeing that patient.
“We’re trying to get these people in and out quickly,” he says. “If we don’t, our payments get stopped, but the physicians continue to get paid.”
Successful teamwork will require more than a new law; it will require a change in the mind-set of everyone involved. Hospitals and doctors are accustomed to doing their own thing, Olson says. Under an ACO, incentives for the partners theoretically would be aligned.
Some providers, says Linda Rodrigue, senior attorney with Kean Miller’s health law regulatory group, will wait for the dust to settle before diving into an ACO. Others might want to be on the front end, helping to influence the models.
Olson, who has been burned by last-minute rule changes to past health care reforms, prefers to wait and see how such collaborations work in other places.
“I’ve been in this business for 30 years,” he says. “I’m not going to chase anything until I know either what I’m going to be chasing or where it’s going to go.”
