Call of duty

Author Profile Image
Sign up for the free Daily Report email – local news about the people, companies and issues that impact business impact business in Baton Rouge and beyond.

A debate over a piece of last year’s financial regulatory overhaul is taking place behind closed boardroom doors and in muted tones beside water coolers.

Part of the hushed nature of the debate has to do with the issue’s complexity and uncertainty. But the overriding reason is the majority of people it will affect most have their mouths covered by some very big hands.

Because they work directly or indirectly for investment giants like Merrill Lynch, Morgan Stanley and a host of others, a majority of Capital Region investment advisers and broker-dealers are not permitted to speak about a recent recommendation by the Securities and Exchange Commission to extend to broker-dealers the same fiduciary duty applied to investment advisers.

Advertisement

“As far as the firm’s guidelines, no one on the local level can speak to that issue,” says a public relations manager for a large bank. “Unfortunately, that’s just how we operate. There are a lot of channels to go through.”

Instead of granting interviews to local affiliates, the biggest players in the game instruct public relations staff members to pass along official comment letters addressed to the SEC, the majority of which reflect support for applying the fiduciary standard to broker-dealers.

But many of their local broker-dealers and registered representatives—investment planners who work for broker-dealers—don’t follow the company line.

A number of them sent opposition letters to the SEC when it was taking comments on the regulation. Off the record, they say extending the fiduciary duty will be an unnecessary burden that ultimately will increase costs and limit competition but won’t significantly improve consumer protection.

“We’re already one of the most heavily regulated industries out there, and it would be redundant to put us under a fiduciary responsibility,” says a Capital Region Certified Financial Planner, who spoke on the condition of anonymity because they lack authorization to comment. “This is just a knee-jerk reaction to a lot of the fraud that’s been perpetuated through the years.”

Signed into law last summer, the focus of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act was to eliminate future bailouts and the possibility of banks becoming “too big to fail,” as well as to increase transparency in the financial industry and to better protect consumers from abusive practices.

The Dodd-Frank Act also gives the SEC authority to extend the fiduciary duty, which requires investor advisers to act in their clients’ best interest. Currently, broker-dealers operate under a less stringent standard of care, requiring them to recommend securities that are suitable for their clients.

Holding broker-dealers to the fiduciary duty, says the financial planner, who has more than a decade of experience and an established client base, would increase administrative and attorney costs that would inevitably be passed along to consumers. The regulation also would cause some broker-dealers to leave the industry, limiting investor options.

The planner says those consequences would be acceptable if they protected investors from falling prey to giant Ponzi schemes like those perpe-?tuated by Allen Stanford and Bernard Madoff. But this planner doubts it would drive out even the small-time crooks in the industry.

“The ones who are going to operate in an unethical manner are just going to find ways to get around added regulation,” the planner says. “I don’t think it will stop either the criminal advisers or the negligent ones.”

Michael Dowden, chief compliance officer for Harger and Company and a Certified Financial Planner, agrees. Still, he says, fiduciary duty should be extended to broker-dealers to ensure better regulation and investor protection.

As a dually licensed firm, Harger and Company adheres to the fiduciary duty regardless of whether its representatives are acting as investment advisers or broker-dealers. The effect of extending the fiduciary duty would be minimal on the small firm, which is one of only several dozen in Louisiana that operate independently from the industry giants.

“It makes everyone more honest,” Dowden says. “To me, it’s really no different than any other rules or regulations that have come down from the SEC in recent years. I know there are a lot of broker-dealers who don’t want to be under the fiduciary duty, but they’re transaction people. The more transactions they do, the more money they make.”

True enough, the anonymous financial planner says. But the idea that broker-dealers are able to force clients into transactions solely for increased commissions is not true. Unlike investment advisers, broker-dealers are heavily regulated outside of the SEC by a number of self-regulatory agencies, including the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, which also supports a uniform standard.

Such organizations monitor broker-dealer transactions, and they can assess fines and suspensions if they find a member is “churning”—recommending too many securities with high commissions or switching clients too often from product to product for increased commissions.

“You can lose your job for doing stuff like that,” the planner says, adding that broker-dealers also have in-house compliance officers reviewing them. “The bottom line is, if you’re doing what you’re supposed to do and following the regulations already in place, there’s enough protections for the customer.”

Another negative consequence of extending the fiduciary duty would be increased lawsuits and retroactive punishment of broker-dealers, opponents say. The planner says peers have no control over their clients’ purse strings and should not be held accountable if they choose not to follow their advice.

“I’ve seen clients buy and sell things when I’ve advised them against it and I didn’t have any power to stop them, so why should I be held responsible for that?” the planner says. “If I wanted that type of responsibility, then I’d go get a different type of license and I’d practice in a different manner.”

The SEC has not officially addressed the six-month study, which was released in January. Two of the five commissioners released a joint statement saying they don’t support the idea. An SEC spokesman says no one will speak on the issue until the commission takes it up at a meeting.

“Will this make it better for a couple investors, while I have to suffer the consequences for the few bad broker-dealers out there?” the planner says. “I hope not, but that remains to be seen.”

FIDUCIARY DUTY VS. SUITABILITY STANDARD

Fiduciary duty requires investment advisers to act in the best interest of their clients, which, as local Certified Financial Planner Michael Dowden says, “basically means if you wouldn’t put your grandmother in this transaction, you shouldn’t put your client in it.” Advisers also are required to disclose any personal conflicts of interest they might have, and place the financial interest of their clients above their own.

Suitability standard holds broker-dealers to a less stringent standard of care for their clients than fiduciary duty. In recommending the sale, purchase or exchange of any security, broker-dealers must have reasonable grounds for believing the recommendation is suitable for the particular client based on facts such as the client’s investment holdings, strategy and overall finances. Under the standard, broker-dealers are not required to disclose personal conflicts of interest.

Discussion (0)

From Our Partners

Daily Report Poll

ASK AI

Ask anything about Baton Rouge business