There has been significant discussion recently about whether or not appraisers should use distressed sales such as foreclosures and short sales as comparables when valuing homes. Opponents say that the inclusion of these sales unnecessarily depresses a home’s value. Supporters want the sales included to reflect real market forces that impact current values. Appraisers just want the situation clarified so they don’t violate any rules.
Four states are now considering legislation that would prohibit or restrict appraisers from using distressed sales when valuing a home. According to the American Banker, the rationale for the bills in Illinois, Nevada, Missouri and Maryland is that “The prevalence of foreclosures and short sales-almost four out of 10 sales in the country are distressed-is distorting the markets.” Realtors and home builders support this legislation because these low appraisals could either prevent a sale or a refinance from occurring or could make new construction unfeasible.
But one of the lenders quoted in the article is worried that excluding these transactions will cause problems. “The notion that you are going to excuse foreclosures from the calculation of value means that as much as you would like it to be higher, the value you are assigning the house will be overstated,” said Bill Uffelman, the president and chief executive of the Nevada Bankers Association. “It will be contributing to a new bubble.”
It is a difficult situation for appraisers. According to the Appraisal Institute, appraisers are required to comply with the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice in federally related transactions. The standard mandates that appraisers “must analyze such comparables sales as are available.” Further, the standard cannot be voided by a state or local government. The Institute says, “Not following USPAP could subject the appraiser to having action taken against their license. Therefore, appraisers would have to make the decision to commit a USPAP violation-which in the case of federally related transactions would be a violation of state law-or to violate the law prohibiting the consideration of distressed sales as comparables.”
This is a difficult issue but one that does impact us here in Louisiana, so we need some public discussion. My solution is to exclude distressed or depressed appraisers from the process, but they all seem a little on edge lately (and you know who I mean) so that really doesn’t work. What do you think?
(Brian Andrews is a certified mortgage banker specializing in the financing of commercial real estate. His business is Andrews Commercial Real Estate Services and he can be reached at brian.andrews@acmla.com.)
