There has been economic chatter recently at the national level concerning a double dip in home prices, or a second round of price declines possible in 2011. The primary proponent of this possibility is Robert Shiller of the Standard & Poors/Case-Shiller home price index.?? One economist who thinks Shiller might be a bit pessimistic about home prices, or at least that the analysis should be made on the local level, says investors should look at the ratio of annual rental rates to home prices to see if home prices are set for a decline. In his August 2009 paper titled “Hitting Bottom? An Updated Analysis of Rents and the Price of Housing? in 100 Metropolitan Areas,” Dean Baker of the Center for Economic and Policy Research said that “a home price that is 15 times the annual rent of a comparable home for rent” was “at an equilibrium sale price” and defined a bubble market as “one in which the ratio of price to annual rent exceeds 18 to 1.” So what about Baton Rouge and other south Louisiana markets? Assuming an average home price in Baton Rouge of about $175,000, the comparable rent would have to be about $975 per month (15-to-1 ratio) to be in equilibrium or about $810 per month (18-to-1 ratio) to be a bubble market ripe for price declines. At the gut level, I feel that prices are probably in equilibrium, though I cannot produce specific data to support my position without further investigation. ??The challenge for potential purchasers is to use data that reflects particular submarkets to see if homes in those areas are priced correctly or not. In other words, consider checking out comparable rents for that $250,000 housing market when shopping for a purchase to see if pricing looks to be in equilibrium or not. Use the 15-to-1 ratio as a general guide and the advice of a good real estate agent to make your final decision.
(Brian Andrews is a certified mortgage banker specializing in the financing of commercial real estate. His business is Andrews Commercial Real Estate Services and he can be reached at brian.andrews@acmla.com.)
