An old adage in real estate is that a property is worth what someone will pay for it, but with distressed properties that adage might not hold true. In such cases, lenders may be willing to dispose of a property for less than it is worth because they do not want to endure the carrying costs or they lack the systems to properly operate the property. After all, lenders are set up to loan money, not to operate rental properties. Savvy investors can therefore pick up good deals in the market by purchasing foreclosed properties at a discounted price (Note: The preceding statement is a sweeping generalization and not always true but, in my opinion, is true in many cases). There will then be the conversation with the new lender to explain why the property is worth more than the purchase price, followed by the really fun conversation.
“How much can I borrow?”
Standard underwriting says that a lender will loan the lower of some percentage of the appraised value, called the Loan-to-Value or LTV constraint; or some percentage of the cost, called the Loan-to-Cost or LTC constraint. Most of the time those percentages are the same. For example, a lender may be willing to lend at the lower of 75% LTV or 75% LTC. Usually this is not an issue, since value and cost are usually close to the same figure. But not so with purchases of distressed properties.
Assume a foreclosed property with a $100,000 appraisal that an investor can buy for $80,000. Based on standard underwriting, the new lender would loan the lower of $75,000 (75% LTV) or $60,000 (75% LTC), deciding on the $60,000 amount and requiring the purchaser to put in $20,000, or 25%, cash equity. At this loan amount the lender has a 60% Loan-to-Value on this transaction. But the purchaser would rather the lender size the loan based solely on the 75% LTV constraint and lend $75,000 or 94% LTC, resulting in a $5,000 cash injection, or about 6% cash equity.
So where does the loan amount wind up? As you might expect, it will probably land somewhere in between. I have seen many deals in the past where a lender will require minimum cash equity of 10% regardless of LTV. In the above example, this would lead to an $8,000 down payment and a $72,000 loan with 72% LTV. Times have changed and lenders are holding to their guns more than ever before, so such flexibility may be harder to find.
In addition to the challenge of determining the final loan amount, there is another question to be addressed when purchasing a distressed property: Why will the project and the loan be successful this time around? We will look at that issue next week.
(Brian Andrews is a certified mortgage banker specializing in the financing of commercial real estate. His business is Andrews Commercial Real Estate Services and he can be reached at brian.andrews@acmla.com.)
