Last week I reported on pending legislation in other states that would restrict appraisers from using distressed sales as comparables when valuing homes. Both sides were presented, as was the difficult position that appraisers would be placed in if this legislation were passed. I ended with a call for public comment and received some noteworthy responses:
Real estate broker: “In my opinion, any subject property that is being appraised for a 30-year loan—and the condition of the property would allow a 30-year loan—should have comps that would also qualify for a 30-year loan.”
Lender: “I believe foreclosures or short sales should only be included in appraisals when the market has an excess of the same. For instance, when the market has greater than 10% of its homes in foreclosure/short sales, then include them as a part of the overall market condition.”
Retired appraiser: “When I was appraising, and now in brokerage, in a normal market, distressed sales are and should be excluded because, by definition, they would distort the market. But … I don’t see how you can ignore what is the market. To ignore it is to ignore reality.”
Students in my finance class: “Will this be on the test?”
I also received a ranting e-mail from a Florida appraiser who apparently thought I had written the pending legislation as a personal affront to appraisers everywhere, when my article was clearly written as a personal affront to only certain appraisers (one, really).
In truth, my opinion on the matter is that we should engage experienced appraisers who can make the appropriate adjustments to current sales, including those adjustments required based on condition, financing and terms of sale; and that all sales should be considered, including distressed sales that are properly adjusted.
Of course, my approach opens a new can of worms: what adjustments to distressed sales are appropriate? I think that is where the discussion needs to be focused and would hope that the parties impacted, beginning with the Appraisal Institute, would have a respectful dialogue along those lines.
(Brian Andrews is a certified mortgage banker specializing in the financing of commercial real estate. His business is Andrews Commercial Real Estate Services and he can be reached at brian.andrews@acmla.com.)
