The people of Louisiana, if the recently released 2011 Louisiana Survey is any indication, are quite the confused lot.
Done annually by LSU and the Reilly Center for Media and Public Affairs, the purpose of the survey is to act as a barometer of public opinion on the operations of state government, taxes and spending priorities, as well as what are deemed to be the most pressing issues facing us as a people and as a state.
There are dozens of pie charts and graphs in the study, ostensibly to make it easy for elected officials and policy wonks to understand the will of the people. The picture that these USA Today-like charts paints, however, is one of contradictory confusion.
Satisfaction over the direction the state is heading is effectively tied to how much money you make and where you live. Overall, rich, white Republican men from north Louisiana are happiest about the state we’re in.
Despite growing concern about the direction Louisiana is heading [“wrong direction” is up 11.5% over the past two years], a whopping 64.8% of respondents are hopeful and optimistic about our future. Essentially, we’re evenly divided about the direction the state is traveling, but an overwhelming majority believe that, wherever we wind up, that destination will be a happy place.
Half of those surveyed are OK with higher taxes to address the state’s projected $1.6 billion shortfall [44% say do it with spending cuts alone]. The issue gets dicey when specific tax proposals are floated. Support for increasing sales and property taxes is dismal, but hiking taxes on the wealthy and those who smoke, drink and/or gamble gets strong majority support.
Nearly 60% believe the repeal of the Stelly Plan [largely viewed as a tax break for the affluent] is a big reason for our current fiscal mess, and 56% are OK with temporarily reinstating Stelly’s tax provisions. Sift through the cross-tabs and it’s clear those who gained little or nothing by Stelly’s demise are perfectly OK with its resurrection. Those whose bank accounts benefited, on the other hand, say Stelly should rest in peace.
Those in the spending cut camp also wave the flag of mixed signals. The least popular proposal is laying off state employees. That said, a majority support privatizing some state government services along with closing select state agency field offices. To recap, we’re OK with privatizing government work and closing some branch offices, but we’re not OK with laying off the workers who did the work we want to privatize or those who work in the offices we want to close.
The two most pressing problems confronting the state, according to the survey, are the economy [35.5%] and education [24%]. Until 2008, our woeful education system was the clear winner as the state’s top problem, with the economy a consistent No. 2. While Louisiana has performed far better than almost every other state during the national recession, it’s clear those who took the survey don’t see life as rosily as do the politicians and economic development wonks.
So it’s ironic that when asked about spending cuts, the favored cow to gore is spending on economic development projects. The folks happiest with LED and the state’s economic development efforts are those living in north Louisiana. I suspect many of those are chicken farmers.
Our views on education are equally vexing. Consider: 45% believe we have too many college campuses, yet 71% oppose consolidation; and 70% of respondents grade the performance of our colleges and universities as either an A or a B, despite claiming higher education is in need of reform.
The news isn’t good for LSU’s flagship campus, as nearly half oppose allowing campuses to go on a tuition-raising spree to offset budget cuts and only 37% believe in the need to maintain a nationally ranked university if that means funding cuts for other colleges and universities.
Most people in this state believe colleges and universities are doing a “good” or “excellent” job of meeting local workforce needs. This should come as a shock to the business community, which regularly complains that finding a skilled and competent workforce is a top problem in this state.
Regardless, what many fail to realize—as evidenced by other responses in the survey—is that our generally poor public K-12 system and a higher education system desperate for overhaul and new philosophies are the very reasons why the economy is such a big worry.
Given our utter state of confusion, is it any wonder our elected officials—other than Gov. Bobby Jindal and his almost singular no-new-tax pledge—are seemingly clueless on the solution front? Apparently we do, indeed, have representative government.
What the survey ultimately reveals is something most of us instinctively already understand: People want change, but only if it doesn’t impact their wallet or anything else they have an affinity toward. In other words: Everyone should feel the pain but me.
There’s no confusion on that point.
