US Senate race retreading themes from Louisiana’s 2015 governor’s race

Author Profile Image
Sign up for the free Daily Report email – local news about the people, companies and issues that impact business impact business in Baton Rouge and beyond.

The historic election for Louisiana governor last year is still reverberating along today’s political landscape. In fact, some of its key themes and players can be found in or around the developing U.S. Senate race.

The big question moving forward will be whether the results will be the same—that is, a Democrat launching a Cinderella bid for the nation’s upper chamber and, in a fairy-tale string of events, winning in a state that often appears more red than blue.

That’s what Gov. John Bel Edwards managed to do in the November runoff against U.S. Sen. David Vitter, who is relinquishing his seat after 17 years on the Hill, including a stint in the House. Edwards, more so than Vitter, has had a consistent presence on the campaign trail so far. But only for Public Service Commissioner Foster Campbell, a fellow Democrat from Elm Grove who wants to replace Vitter.

Advertisement

Edwards is helping to raise money for Campbell, and the governor’s image was used in a recent web video produced by the Campbell campaign. There are even a few top aides that Edwards relied on in 2015 that are now working with Campbell. The bond between the two men seems to be strong, representing something that transcends politics.

At a New Orleans fundraiser for Campbell about four weeks ago, Edwards said, “I hate to say it this way, but I see a lot of either who I am or what I aspire to be in Foster.”

Recapturing the exact same kind of lightning in a bottle will be tough for Campbell, but his campaign is quick to point out that they are not trying precisely to duplicate the 2015 success Democrats enjoyed. Still, Campbell, in some respects, is starting to run against the same opponent Edwards had last year. It’s not a completely outside-the-box strategy, but it hinges on voters feeling totally displeased with Vitter’s service in the Senate.

Edwards, in comparison, ran a personality-driven campaign against Vitter, which was easier to sell. And Edwards didn’t have any Democrats to fend off last year. Campbell, though, has at least two other Democrats vying for the open Senate seat: Denham Springs attorney Caroline Fayard and Acadiana oil executive Josh Pellerin.

Since announcing his candidacy, Campbell has sought to slay Vitter on a few different issues. Campbell went after the senior senator when an unsourced news report claimed Vitter was trying to line up a lobbying job for his post-Senate career. Campbell likewise issued a news release describing Vitter’s call for the resignation of Veterans Affairs Secretary Bob McDonald as “insincere.”

Simply put, some candidates run best when they have someone to run against. Vitter, while not the incumbent, may become a regular target for Campbell.

Edwards, meanwhile, has become a target for Treasurer John Kennedy, who is maintaining a lead in most of the publicly released U.S. Senate polls. Kennedy has given countless media interviews over the past few months opposing the governor’s tax proposals. Last week he also appeared on a Baton Rouge television station and actually asked lawmakers to end early the year’s second special session that Edwards called.

Like Vitter in 2015, Kennedy has several Republicans working overtime to knock him down a few points, including U.S. Rep. Charles Boustany, who is the closest within reach. It should create some interesting party politics, with as many as six big-name Republicans that could qualify.

On the money front, last year’s race for governor ended up being the most expensive in Louisiana history. While the developing race for the U.S. Senate may not break the same kind of records, it could get close. There are already 10 declared candidates overall, and the list could grow, however slightly, in the coming weeks. Half of the contenders will likely have formidable campaign accounts. A few will likewise have independent super PACs supporting them that are already collecting unlimited individual donations.

Then there are the third-party groups, like nonprofits, that will be spending cash to influence your vote. For instance, the conservative Club For Growth, based in D.C., has endorsed Fleming and recently appeared on TV in Louisiana questioning the votes of Boustany. (Keep in mind, there are still roughly five months to go until the November primary.)

While each Louisiana election is unique, and the Senate race will undoubtedly stand on its own, the similarities at this point are worth a review. The most striking parallel may involve voter apathy.

Edwards and Vitter had to fight to get the attention of voters last year. No one wanted to tune in until the very end. The candidates for the U.S. Senate this year may face the same challenge, as there’s very little to draw voters in right now.

But the race, regardless, will start in earnest soon. Let’s just hope it eventually grabs our collective attention for all the right reasons.

—Jeremy Alford

Jeremy Alford publishes LaPolitics Weekly, a newsletter on Louisiana politics, at LaPolitics.com. Follow him on Twitter, or on Facebook. He can be reached at JJA@LaPolitics.com.

Discussion (0)

From Our Partners

Daily Report Poll

ASK AI

Ask anything about Baton Rouge business