For more than two decades, St. Tammany Parish has enjoyed the distinction of being one of the shining success stories in a state that has more than its share of failures. With low crime, high salaries, pricey real estate and the best public school district in all of Louisiana, the charmingly-rural-yet-stylishly-exurban Northshore parish could rightly claim the nickname given it by adoring residents: “God’s country.”
But recent statistics suggest there is trouble in paradise. St. Tammany Parish had the highest foreclosure rate in the state for much of last year, home sale prices continue to decline, and a 10-year inventory of luxury homes valued at $1 million or more glut the high-end market. The problems are not just confined to the real estate sector, either. Unemployment is up, retail sales are down and—perhaps as result of all this—the suicide rate in St. Tammany is the highest in the state.
Is the bloom off the rose of what has been the jewel of southeast Louisiana, or is the Northshore’s flagship parish merely experiencing the kind of downturn that is affecting the rest of the nation?
Experts say it’s primarily the latter, noting that the economic slowdown in St. Tammany mirrors national trends and really isn’t so bad, compared to many places. But they also point out that it may seem more acute than it actually is because for so long St. Tammany experienced such unbridled growth—and after Katrina, it positively exploded.
“The Northshore economy was growing and becoming more diversified, and that really fueled a lot of expectations for future growth,” says Ivan Miestchovich, director of the Institute for Real Estate and Economic Development at the University of New Orleans. “Then Katrina came and brought those expectations to higher levels, and a lot of those expectations didn’t pan out.”
So just how bad is the real estate picture in St. Tammany? The most alarming statistic is the foreclosure rate, which for the first six months of 2010 was the highest in the state at one out of every 405 housing units. By October, it had climbed even higher—to one out of every 376, though by then Jefferson Parish had actually surpassed it, with one out of every 326 housing units in foreclosure.
It is important to note that while St. Tammany’s foreclosure rate is three times higher than the state average, it’s still lower than in many parts of the country. Florida’s foreclosure rate, on average, is one out of every 155, while Nevada’s is one in 80—and that’s the average, which means in some counties it’s a lot worse.
Experts say more significant than how many properties are in foreclosure is who is being foreclosed upon in St. Tammany. Is it developers who became overleveraged in the post-Katrina building bubble or individual mortgage holders who are unemployed and unable to make their monthly house notes?
It’s hard to say for sure, but it is clear that much of the foreclosure activity is directly related to the post-Katrina housing frenzy, and a lot of those now in trouble are developers or investors.
“A lot of the foreclosure activity is against builders who built inventory on the expectation that there were going to be buyers, and those buyers never materialized,” Miestchovich says. “And a lot of speculators bought a house on the expectation they’d be able to flip it in a year or two and then found themselves stretched because their income didn’t keep up … or because they lost their job.”
Regrettably, though, it’s not only developers and investors driving up the foreclosure rate. Realtors say all too often they hear from Katrina victims who relocated to the Northshore and bought their family’s dream home at an inflated price, only to now be dealing with the nightmare of losing it.
“I hear it all the time and it’s really sad,” says Wayne Mayberry, owner of Real Estate Resource Group in Covington. “You hate to hear from someone who you thought you had done a wonderful job for post-Katrina … and now they’re calling you in tears because they’re out of a job and they’re going to lose the house you sold them and they don’t know what to do.”
Average home sale prices are also continuing on a downward trend, though 2010 was not as bad as 2009. During the first nine months of 2009, home sale prices were down more than 6% from the same period in the previous year. During the first nine months of 2010, they were down another 1%, with the eastern part of the parish experiencing slightly more of a decline than the western part.
Granted, St. Tammany Parish values did not decline as much as those in some parts of the Northshore. Average home sale prices in neighboring Tangipahoa, for instance, declined more than 10% from 2008 to 2009, and another 8% from 2009 to 2010.
Part of the problem is the simple dynamic of supply and demand, according to Realtors. Too many new homes were built on the Northshore after Katrina. With the oversupply came reductions in price. That’s especially evident in the high-end segment of the market. Between January and November last year, only five houses in St. Tammany Parish sold for $1 million or more, while 50 others languished on the market. That’s a 10-year inventory, given the parish’s current rate of absorption.
“If you’ve got a million-dollar home in St. Tammany, this is not the time to sell,” says Mayberry. “I’ve got several spectacular listings right now and I’m not getting shows or even inquiries—and these are magnificent houses.”
As an example, Mayberry points to a high-end listing he’s had on the market for almost a year in the tony Brookstone subdivision in Covington. The 7,100-square-foot house belongs to a local builder and includes such amenities as toe warmers in all five bathrooms and an outdoor gourmet kitchen. The original list price of $1.6 million was reduced to $1.3 million, then $1.2 million, and still there is no interest.
Not that homes listing for even half that much are having an easier time. Builders say they’re starting to see activity pick up again in the low-end segment of the market, but not with anything above $400,000.
“Bigger spec houses are taking a beating,” says Kenny Adams, president of the St. Tammany/Washington Parishes Home Builders Association. “The ones who are doing smaller houses are the only ones doing well.”
Of course, the problems in the residential real estate market are related to problems in other segments of the economy, in some instances causing them, in other instances resulting from them. Take the unemployment rate, for instance. It reached more than 5.6% last year in St. Tammany, compared to 3.7% in 2009. While that’s a sobering statistic, it’s still well below the state and national averages of 7.2% and 9.5 %, respectively.
Retail sales are also down. In the second quarter of 2010 they were 3.4% lower than in the second quarter of 2009. Sales for the first half of the year, meanwhile, were down 5.4% compared to the same period the year before.
To what extent the real estate and economic downturn is affecting the mood and quality of life in St. Tammany Parish depends on who you talk to—and what part of the parish is at issue. Old Covington, with its historic homes and quaint, upscale shopping district, remains as charming and desirable as ever. Other parts of the parish that have been more affected by the burst of the housing bubble are seeing the trickle-down effects.
As an example, a Realtor points to a strip center off I-12 that was supposed to be a high-end shopping destination when conceived several years ago, with a Macy’s and a Ruth’s Chris Steak House, among other retailers. Then came Katrina, and then came the banking crisis, and the developer went bankrupt. The property was sold through the U.S. Bankruptcy Court, and recently opened with a Hobby Lobby and Kohl’s as its anchor tenants.
“That’s one of the uglies,” says the Realtor, who asked not to be identified. “It sort of epitomizes to me what has happened to some parts of this parish since Katrina.”
In what some have tried to interpret as a sign of the troubles, St. Tammany has the highest suicide rate in Louisiana. There were 33 in 2009, nearly double the number in 2002. While that sounds like an alarming statistic, it’s important to note that the number of suicides in the parish has been steadily climbing, and in 2007 it was actually higher than in 2009. Experts say that suggests that whatever factors are driving the suicide rate are not related to the recent downturn in the economy per se.
James Hartman, who wears two hats as spokesman for the St. Tammany Economic Development Foundation and a board member for the St. Tammany Outreach for the Prevention of Suicides, notes that the median age of those who commit suicide in St. Tammany Parish is late 40s to early 50s, which is considerably younger than the national average. That suggests the pressures are related to expectations of financial and professional achievement that are typical in affluent societies.
“There’s a lot of social pressure, and people mistakenly believe that affluence minimizes those sorts of emotions, and that’s not true,” says Hartman. “In some cases affluence can exacerbate those emotions.”
Hartman is quick to point out that while there are many economic statistics that suggest St. Tammany has been hit by the double whammy of a national recession and the burst of the post-Katrina bubble, there are other statistics to suggest that things are already turning around. Among them: single-family building permits in 2010 were up nearly 25% over 2009, the volume of home sales was also up, and there were more new startup businesses last year over the year before.
There is anecdotal evidence, too, that the economic difficulties of the last couple of years are beginning to ease. Home builders say their suppliers are busy again, and that subcontractors who were available to do any odd job last year are now booked up.
“I’m having a much harder time finding people,” says Adams. “But I’m not complaining. That’s a good thing.”
What remains a feather in the cap of St. Tammany is that its school system continues to rank as the best in the state, which ensures that the area will remain desirable for young, middle-class families. Also, given the plethora of available homes in a variety of price points, industry watchers believe once the economy picks up, St. Tammany will be poised for a strong rebound.
“As long as our school system remains phenomenal this is going to be an in-demand area,” says Mayberry. “We may not continue to grow at the same pace, but nothing ever stays the same.”
