Tommy Spinosa speaks out

Author Profile Image
Sign up for the free Daily Report email – local news about the people, companies and issues that impact business impact business in Baton Rouge and beyond.

For a man who has spent the better part of the past two years quietly battling multiple lawsuits that threaten to destroy his reputation, livelihood and legacy, developer Joseph T. “Tommy” Spinosa looks and sounds no worse for the wear.

He strides confidently into a boardroom overlooking an afternoon crowd relaxing in Perkins Rowe’s town center, poised, polite, neatly groomed and dressed in a casual cardigan and slacks. He makes a little small talk, straightens a stack of papers on the table and sits next to his public relations manager, who hands him a glass of ice water.

Spinosa takes a sip, clears his throat and asks if his first lengthy interview since becoming embroiled in a number of highly publicized lawsuits—including a foreclosure attempt on Perkins Rowe and a $12 million suit over a smaller mixed-use development in Mandeville called Chenier Apartments and Shops—is ready to begin.

Advertisement

“My attorneys have pretty much told me to keep my mouth shut,” he says straightaway.

Not once in the next 45 minutes does Spinosa ask to go off the record, and only occasionally does he noticeably parse his words. He exhibits little or no signs of being uncomfortable—his hands never fidget, and his eyes never dart—and his tone also never waivers with any emotion, even when discussing the effects his legal troubles have had on his business and on decades-old relationships with area subcontractors.

Perhaps it’s the sheer amount of litigation he’s wading through, but as Spinosa systematically explains the contracts, construction certificates and lawsuits he’s brought along, it sounds as if he could represent himself in the courtroom. If there were lawyers present, this meeting might resemble a deposition. And for Spinosa, it possibly feels like one.

Were it not for potential legal repercussions, Spinosa says, he’d love to talk about the Perkins Rowe foreclosure suit that Cleveland-based KeyBank National Association initiated 21 months ago because of the millions it claims he owes on a $170 million loan. He says he’ll give his side of that story as soon as possible.

In the interim, he’s going against his attorneys’ advice, speaking on the record to defend himself concerning the $12 million suit that Hartford, Conn.-based Travelers Casualty & Surety Company of America brought against him last fall over unpaid subcontractors at the Chenier development.

But for the subcontractors caught up in the suit, the years of squabbling and turmoil could not have come at a worse time. In addition to the industry freefall they’ve endured during the recession, they’ve been negatively impacted by lost revenue and attorney’s fees. One subcontractor says he’s teetering on the brink of bankruptcy. Another says she’s laid off most of her staff, sold her home and vacated her former office in order to keep her finances down. And while some subcontractors say they’ll never work with Spinosa again, others remain loyal to him.

Whatever their grievances, Spinosa has explanations, most of which deflect attention from him.

“There are a lot of misconceptions out there,” he says, “and there’s nothing more I’d like to do than get the truth out.”

The suit

In 2006, Travelers issued performance and payment bonds to Spinosa and his Echelon Construction Company for two mixed-use developments, Chenier Apartments and Shops in Mandeville and Perkins Rowe in Baton Rouge.

On both projects, dozens of subcontractors claim Echelon did not pay them as the jobs were nearing completion. Many also say they never received the standard 10% retainage due when the work was finished. The Travelers suit combines claims filed against the bonding company in 2008 and 2009 for work on Chenier and Perkins Rowe. Spinosa says the projects have different circumstances and need to be regarded separately.

Unlike Perkins Rowe, Spinosa does not own the $30 million Chenier development, which was completed in March 2009, about a year and a half after Perkins Rowe. The development is owned by Chenier Property Partners, and Echelon served as the construction manager on the project. In essence, Spinosa says, Echelon is in the same boat as the subcontractors who have filed claims for nonpayment.

“This is a simple case of developers not paying the contractor; therefore, the contractor cannot pay the subs,” he says. “Obviously, we play a much larger role in Perkins Rowe … where we’re knee-deep in this thing in all kinds of ways.”

To a person reading through the paperwork regarding the lawsuit, it might appear that the relationship between Travelers and Echelon is adversarial; Spinosa contends that it’s not. Instead, he says the insurance company is working with Echelon on what he calls “a united front” to pay subcontractors, as well as to recover about $4 million from Chenier Property Partners in a separate suit.

“I have a team working with Travelers on a daily basis, and they have their own independent consultant who evaluates everything we did and everything the contractors did to come to a final conclusion,” Spinosa says. “Travelers is satisfied [Chenier Property Partners] owes us the money. What we did, because of the tremendous amount of litigation going on, I just couldn’t handle it all, so Travelers and I have agreed that they’re taking over the case.”

Neither attorneys for Travelers nor company representatives would comment on the lawsuits involving Spinosa. Chenier Property Partners didn’t return calls; in court filings, it contends final payment was withheld from Echelon because a punch list was not satisfactorily completed. It also says Echelon refused requests for a certification of actual cost, which is required in its contract.

Spinosa denies those claims, and points to certificates of completion filed with the St. Tammany Parish Clerk of Court and the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, which insured the loan for the Chenier project. He says the documents prove the job was satisfactorily completed and accepted by Chenier Property Partners.

“This is signed by the owner, it’s signed by the architect, it’s signed by the contractor and it’s filed. … It certifies that the owner has accepted the job,” Spinosa says, holding up the certificate filed with the clerk of court. “I believe, and Travelers believes also … that we’re going to win this case and we’re going to get our money.”

MISERY LOVES COMPANY: Echelon Construction Company served as the construction manager on the $30 million Chenier Apartments and Shops project in Mandeville, and developer Tommy Spinosa says Echelon is in the same boat as the subcontractors who have filed claims for nonpayment.

The settlements

Though Travelers might be working with Spinosa in a suit against Chenier Property Partners, there’s still the $12 million suit it has against him to recoup settlements paid to subcontractors.

“They’re coming after me. I’m not going to run away from that,” Spinosa says. “What we’re doing is working hand in hand with Travelers to get these subcontractors paid and out of the middle, and Travelers and I will get our issues resolved later.”

Of the 22 subcontractors included in the Travelers suit for work at Chenier, he says, all but six have received a settlement, and two currently are negotiating a settlement.

“We’re doing our damnedest to be sure everybody gets paid as much as they’re due, to the greatest extent possible, subject to them having performed their work,” Spinosa says. “But I do know a couple of them will not [get paid] because Travelers and I have concurred we’ve got some serious problems with their work.”

Baton Rouge-based B&D Electric performed about $2 million worth of work at Chenier and is included in the Travelers suit; it sued for about $283,000, the amount it says remained outstanding. Though it received a $270,000 settlement after two years of legal wrangling, B&D President Robert Pendarvis doesn’t credit Spinosa for playing a role in it.

“It had nothing to do with him. Tommy was nowhere to be found after we filed our lien, and he never communicated with us once after we got into the court system,” Pendarvis says, adding that he declined an offer from Echelon to work at Perkins Rowe following the troubles with Chenier.

That Pendarvis and others have even received settlements is proof, Spinosa says, that he has been working to get them paid. Because of a pay-when-paid clause included in all of Echelon’s contracts, which states the subcontractors will receive payment once the owners have paid Echelon, Travelers isn’t legally obligated to pay any settlements on the Chenier project, he says.

“It’s happening on the Perkins Rowe side, too,” says Jeff Wright of Wright Feigley Communications, a public relations firm hired by Spinosa. “In many cases, they’re not obligated to pay.”

All but eight of the 27 subcontractors who filed claims in the Travelers suit over work at Perkins Rowe have received settlements, and two others currently are working on settlements, according to documents provided by Spinosa. The other six either are accused of defective work or have legal issues with their claim, he says.

Pendarvis doesn’t believe he would have received a settlement if it were not for a slight change of wording his attorney made to the pay-when-paid clause before B&D Electric started work on Chenier. B&D’s settlement was about $13,000 less than its claim, and Pendarvis says he’s spent about as much in attorney’s fees. Nonetheless, he’s just glad he recouped any money.

“We feel very fortunate to be where we are in relation to a lot of our friends who have taken a real hit in the Spinosa saga,” he says. “Business is as tough as it’s ever been, and the amount of losses some people have absorbed in this deal can have a devastating effect on a small business. There’s been a lot of people hurt, no doubt about it.”

The subs

One such company is Baton Rouge-based Garco Inc., which has been in business for eight years and has about 12 employees.

Owners John Gomez and Alex Garcia say they were never paid for about $80,000 worth of drywall and other work at Perkins Rowe. They also performed about $300,000 worth of work at Chenier, they say, for which they were paid, albeit late.

As small-business owners trying to survive the recession, Gomez and Garcia say the losses have put them in jeopardy of bankruptcy. Garco received a small settlement from Travelers for some of its work at Perkins Rowe, Gomez says, but they’re still out about $65,000, plus thousands in attorney’s fees.

“We’re really struggling,” Gomez says. “Our No. 1 priority is paying our guys, who count on us to support their families—and we’ve done that—so our business has really taken a hit. Imagine having $65,000 taken out of your pocket.”

The financial losses, coupled with the lack of business caused by the economic downturn, have had a crippling effect, Garcia says. Their savings have been depleted, which means they can’t afford to put up bid bonds on large jobs. Even if they could, he says, they couldn’t afford the equipment necessary to perform any work on a large scale because they’re behind on paying their suppliers.

“It will take two to three years to make back what we lost, and that’s if the economy picks up like it was a few years ago,” Garcia says. “We’ve been in business for eight years, and we have no money in the bank because of things like this. But what can you do? We just have to keep working and take everything day to day.”

JoAnn Osborne, owner of Osborne Scott Construction, says she received an undisclosed settlement from Travelers last month after nearly three years of legal squabbling over stucco work at Chenier and Perkins Rowe.

During that time, Osborne says, she’s cut nearly all of her staff, sold her home and started renting again to keep her expenses down. She’s also vacated her former office and moved into a smaller space with a longtime business partner.

“This has consumed three years of my life, and it’s been pure hell. It just broke us all,” Osborne says, noting her settlement was for tens of thousands less than her actual losses. “I just want to get back to basics and start over, get some of this behind me.”

About a dozen subcontractors involved in the Travelers suit declined to comment. Some of them say it’s because they’re still hoping to collect in the Travelers suit, and their attorneys have advised them not to talk publicly.

Others say it’s because they don’t want to fray their working relationship with Spinosa, despite having claims against him, some valuing hundreds of thousands of dollars. It’s a peculiar situation, and one that only makes sense if you consider the long relationships some of them have had with Spinosa.

The history

Despite her losses, Osborne is one of a number of subcontractors who express what some might consider a surprising amount of empathy and lasting respect for Spinosa.

“Tommy had vision. His intentions were good, and he did something for Baton Rouge that needed to be done,” she says. “He’s done a lot for this city, and I think that point has been lost in all the allegations and lawsuits.”

Osborne’s been in the construction business for more than 30 years, and her working relationship with Spinosa goes back nearly as long. History factors into her forgiving tone. Though she hasn’t spoken with Spinosa in years, she considered him a friend before the problems at Chenier and Perkins Rowe.

Still, she doesn’t blame Spinosa for those problems, saying his only mistake was hiring “the wrong people” to oversee the projects. Osborne says she “would have to be a fool” to subcontract for Echelon again, but adds she wouldn’t think twice about working on a personal project for Spinosa.

Associated Concrete Contractors owner Will Kapavik also doesn’t blame Spinosa for the $2.11 million claim he had to file against Travelers for work at Chenier and Perkins Rowe. The Texas-based company received a $1.15 million settlement from Travelers, and Kapavik says he doesn’t expect to get any more.

“Taking the settlement has a lot to do with the economy,” he says. “I don’t think I could have held out and gotten more money, and we needed the money at the time.”

Despite taking about a $1 million loss on about $35 million worth of work, Kapavik calls Spinosa a “man of his word,” adding that he would have no qualms about subcontracting for him again.

“I’ve been in this business for 34 years, and believe me, I’ve run across plenty of people who will try to screw you out of money, and Tommy is not one of them,” Kapavik says. “I mean, no matter how the media has painted this deal, Tommy has never tried to run from this. He’s gotten a very bad rap, and he doesn’t deserve what he’s been going through in Baton Rouge.”

Through the 45 years B&D Electric has been in business, it’s contracted with Spinosa on a number of projects dating back decades. Pendarvis even helped wire Spinosa’s home years ago. Though he doesn’t hold a grudge against Spinosa, Pendarvis says he also doesn’t have much, if any, sympathy for him. When asked about the possibility of inking a contract with one of Spinosa’s companies again in the future, he just laughs.

“Hopefully I’ve got enough business sense not to work for him, based on his track record,” Pendarvis says. “I’m not hostile to him, but I don’t want to work for him, either.”

Once all of the claims have been resolved, Spinosa says, he expects to work with many of the contractors involved in the Travelers suit. He expresses sympathy for those who performed quality work and were not able to be paid in full, but he adds there were some disgruntled subcontractors who either didn’t complete their jobs or didn’t perform quality work and should not be paid.

“I’ve got a 20- to 30-year relationship with some of these people that goes way back, which is why I want them to get paid,” he says. “We get phone calls from a lot of them weekly, looking for work. They’re caught up in this economic mess just like we are.”

Expressing sympathy is one thing, but taking responsibility for every hardship that subcontractors in the Travelers suit have experienced over the past few years—for which Spinosa feels the media has tried to blame him—is something he will not do.

The effects of the recession, Spinosa says, have had just as big an impact, if not bigger, on the struggling subcontractors involved in the Travelers suit.

“The multifamily housing industry, which has always been Echelon’s bread and butter, and the primary kind of work most of these subcontractors do, almost doesn’t exist today,” he says. “To hear you say that some of [the subcontractors] have had to step down on employees and office space—I’m probably the No. 1 or No. 2 office owner in Baton Rouge, and I can tell you that’s happening in every office building with every type of company there is.”

The spotlight

If there’s one answer that Spinosa doesn’t have, it’s why the media has been so interested in his legal problems.

He expresses surprise that the Travelers suit received any publicity, and he says that reports on the Perkins Rowe foreclosure routinely favor his accusers and portray him in a negative light. Wright has to interject only a few times to keep Spinosa from straying too far into matters concerning Perkins Rowe.

“I feel burned. … The whole story has not been told,” Spinosa says of the blow-by-blow reporting on the lawsuits. “That’s why, on this Travelers issue, I approached Jeff [Wright] and said, ‘Jeff, I need to get the record straight here.’”

Spinosa has come prepared, presenting his position in a logical tone and at a methodical clip. But it’s also clear he doesn’t trust the media. He says the media has unfairly singled him out, while other developers and contractors who have run into disputes with banks and project owners because of economic conditions beyond their control have been given a pass.

“There’s a lot more of this all over town, if you wanted to look,” he says. “I’m just asking for fairness.”

There’s no question Spinosa’s story is newsworthy, if only because the $200 million Perkins Rowe has become one of the most popular developments in the Capital Region since opening in October 2007. Several of the restaurant chains broke first-year attendance records within their franchise groups.

Beyond that, Spinosa has a track record of more than 30 years in residential, retail and office developments. Many people have had some degree of contact with him or his properties, including former LSU and current Alabama football coach Nick Saban, whose name has surfaced in the Perkins Rowe suit and who also is a 49.5% owner of a Houston apartment complex for which another of Spinosa’s companies has filed for bankruptcy protection. Saban perhaps is the only person who has kept a stricter silence than Spinosa.

At least some of the media attention paid to Spinosa is also linked to the Rouzan mixed-use development under construction off Perkins Road, about 3 miles away from Perkins Rowe. Since Spinosa began presenting the 120-acre mixed-use traditional neighborhood development to the planning commission in 2007, opposition from Southdowns neighbors has largely focused on concerns about drainage, density and increased traffic.

But less-than-subtle references to the lawsuits at Perkins Rowe, as well as questions about Spinosa’s business ethics and financial ability, also have entered the conversation, introduced by people opposed to the project, as well as by some Metro Council members.

Spinosa has long maintained Rouzan has nothing to do with Perkins Rowe, saying it has separate contractors and financing. Echelon Construction, which in reality only exists on paper today, is not involved, he says.

Spinosa’s son, Tommy Spinosa III, is managing Rouzan. The first residential phase, called the Mimosa District and comprising 26 homes, is well under way, with homes expected to begin construction in the coming months. The Planning and Zoning Commission in February approved a final development plan for the second phase, which is composed of a pair of five-story buildings to be used for residential, retail and office space.

The future

Even before Echelon volunteered its contractor’s license for revocation by the Louisiana State Licensing Board for Contractors in fall 2009, Spinosa says, the company was all but abolished. Since then, Echelon has been whittled down to a handful of employees whose only objective is to deal with the lawsuits in which the company is involved.

“All they do all day is work with Travelers on bringing as much of this to a head as possible so we can move forward,” Spinosa says. “We’re focusing on getting this stuff behind us. We’re working through it as best we can, and we’ll continue to be there every day to face up to the challenges we have and to satisfy our obligations.”

While some people have suggested Spinosa profited while stiffing subcontractors, he denies such claims and says the company suffered substantial losses on both projects.

“All I can tell you is it’s way less than at Perkins Rowe,” he says of losses at Chenier, though he doesn’t divulge a specific amount. “It’s insignificant in the scheme of things.”

Even if he wasn’t battling the Travelers suit, KeyBank’s foreclosure on Perkins Rowe or other lawsuits, Spinosa doubts he’d have many projects in the pipeline because of the economy.

“It’s been a painful [experience],” he says matter-of-factly. “We want to get paid, and it hurts when you don’t. [The subcontractors] want to get paid, and we know the impacts on their businesses. It’s just like the impact has been on our business in this, the worst economy of my lifetime.”

Still, Spinosa weathered the recession of the 1980s and believes he can overcome the obstacles before him now. His project list next year includes a 166-room hotel at Perkins Rowe, a 135-unit multifamily development called the Lofts at CitiPlace, and a mixed-use development in Biloxi, Miss., with 350 multifamily residences and 80,000 square feet of retail and office space.

“We believe it’s coming back strong, and we’re poised to take advantage of it when it does with my core group, which is still with me,” Spinosa says.

He expects the Travelers suit, as well as the one against Chenier Property Partners, will be settled shortly. Meanwhile, the KeyBank foreclosure suit, in which the consortium of banks alleges Spinosa fraudulently doctored project costs to secure the $170 million loan, is looking to be nearing a summary judgment. However, Spinosa says there’s really no telling when it might conclude.

“This is complex. It’s complicated and there’s a lot of fireworks going on,” Spinosa says. “All I ask is the Chenier matter be put in its proper perspective. This is a case of a contractor not getting paid by the owner, which is exactly what the media has been beating me up about at Perkins Rowe—and we’ll address Perkins Rowe when the timing is right.”

Click here to see a list of claims against Spinosa’s companies in the Travelers case.

Discussion (0)

From Our Partners

Daily Report Poll

ASK AI

Ask anything about Baton Rouge business