The Gulf of Mexico received a lot of attention after the Deepwater Horizon rig exploded and sank last April. Now that the well is capped and skimmers gone, people are wondering about the long term, asking whether the oil has lastingly damaged Louisiana’s fishing industry. This is a valid question, but one that needs to be answered in context.
In your mind’s eye, picture a map of the Gulf of Mexico, then zoom in on the northern Gulf including Louisiana. Draw a slightly curved line between Biloxi, Miss., and Galveston, Texas. All of the land below this
line in Louisiana was built by the Mississippi River as it formed, and then abandoned, a series of deltas over thousands of years as the river changed course in search of the most efficient route to the Gulf. These actions consist of cycles of simultaneous creation and decay of delta lobes, creating the Mississippi River deltaic plain that today is comprised of vast areas of wetlands and marshes, and is one of the most productive areas in the world for fisheries, waterfowl, oysters, and a myriad of other freshwater and marine life forms.
However, this ecosystem is in peril. Because of the 1927 Mississippi flood that inundated thousands of square miles of U.S. farmland, levees have been built on the river’s banks that now permanently constrain it within them. But the levees are slowly strangling the Louisiana delta by preventing natural overbank flooding, thus depriving the lands of most of the freshwater and sediments that built and nourished them. Consequently, the delta is slowly dying because man has altered natural hydrology and interrupted the cycle of delta creation, leaving behind only decay and land loss.
Yet, despite these insults, fisheries productivity dependent upon the deltaic ecosystem has not appreciably declined. Louisiana alone accounts for around 75% of all of the commercial fishery landings in the U.S. Gulf, but also accounts for more than 80% of the nation’s total annual coastal land loss. Continued degradation of Louisiana’s delta makes knowledge of the relationship between land loss and fish production critical—but as of yet unknown. Studies of other deltaic ecosystems hint that we may be approaching an important nexus in the history of fish production in the northern Gulf; fish production can remain high for extended periods beyond the time when ecological conditions are optimal, only to decline rapidly if cumulative impacts reach a tipping point.
How close are we to the tipping point? And is the oil spill in the northern Gulf capable of affecting the tipping point? We don’t yet know the answers, and it is difficult to say so early in the assessment of longer-term impacts, but given recent findings that large amounts of oil are still present on the seafloor in offshore waters, some impacts on fisheries production are likely. In addition, because we know that oil and dispersants reached Louisiana’s coastal marshes and wetlands, it is likely to impact the value of these habitats to fishes, shrimp, oysters and crabs among others, along with sea birds and marine mammals, for years to come. So my biggest fear is that those responsible for this environmental insult will be long gone before the full extent of the impacts are known, thus leaving Louisianans to fend for themselves once again.
