Several hundred people are gathered inside the Old State Capitol for the official unveiling of the vision for FuturEBR, potentially East Baton Rouge Parish’s next comprehensive plan. A few minutes into his remarks, Mayor Kip Holden thanks his staff for their work getting residents to fill out their census forms last year.
“We are now all aware of the results we have achieved, being the largest parish in the state of Louisiana,” he says before pausing. “Being the largest parish in the state of Louisiana,” he says again. This time, the crowd recognizes its cue and applauds.
East Baton Rouge added fewer than 30,000 people over the past 10 years, according to recently released 2010 census figures, but population losses in the New Orleans area were enough to push the parish over the top. Ascension and Livingston, however, each grew by nearly 40%.
John Fregonese, the Portland, Ore.-based planner leading FuturEBR, says the city needs to capture more of that housing growth. If current trends continue, with most job growth inside the city and most housing growth in the suburbs, his work shows gridlock is inevitable.
“I have never seen a transportation model turn so bad,” he says. “The solution is not just widening roads or buying new roads. You need every trick in the book.”
Trick No. 1 is creating a more efficient land-use pattern, with more housing closer to where people work. But attracting people into the city requires making its neighborhoods more attractive to a range of ages and income levels. Downtown, the Southern University/Metro Airport area, Old South Baton Rouge and, especially, Mid City hold tremendous redevelopment potential, Fregonese believes.
“Mid City is just right at that turning point,” he says. “You change the business climate [with a few projects], and the private sector is going to be doing a lot of this stuff on its own. You see that actually happening around LSU a little bit.” He says FuturEBR will incorporate planning work already done for downtown and Old South Baton Rouge.
Not that the plan is anti-suburb, Fregonese says. Suburban development, especially in the southern part of the parish, is expected to continue. But the plan envisions integrating more opportunities for jobs and shopping into those neighborhoods, and less of the traditional model of the isolated cul-de-sac.
One of the key job growth centers is expected to be well away from the older parts of the city, between the Mall of Louisiana and the Pennington Biomedical Research Center, in what is promoted as a South Medical District. The plan calls for the area to be integrated almost like a single campus, with more connecting roads and infill development.
“This could be almost like a new downtown,” Fregonese says. “This will outperform the downtown in terms of job growth.” The plan envisions a streetcar line from the mall, through LSU into downtown, and the long-discussed regional rail line to New Orleans could have a stop in the middle of the medical district.
Political will and plenty of money
Actually putting a plan into action will take political will—the parish doesn’t enforce existing rules mandating street connectivity—and lots of money.
The bus system could be the backbone of the parish’s transportation network, the vision document says, but only by doubling the annual investment. The tax proposal voters narrowly rejected last year would nearly have done just that.
Capital Area Transit System CEO Brian Marshall says the public might be more willing to support the system when they see how it fits into the FuturEBR master plan. Florida Boulevard, Plank Road, Airline Highway and Nicholson Drive are potential high-capacity transit corridors, planners say.
“It’s difficult when people see the system as it is,” he says. “People need to see the system as it could be.”
In other cities, public money is often used to prime the real estate pump, which is the raison d’ętre of the East Baton Rouge Redevelopment Authority. CEO Walter Monsour says the authority is coming into its own just as FuturEBR is getting close to wrapping up.
“We couldn’t have planned it any better,” he says.
Justifying new government outlays will be difficult in the current environment, and many people will object to public incentives for private development. But Monsour argues cities like Pittsburgh have shown how targeted public investments can turn around whole communities.
“It’s not forever and ever going to be an incentivized situation,” he says. Incentives are meant to spark development in an economically risky area, which in theory spurs private-sector investment and allows the public entity to step back.
The FuturEBR consultants held forums and workshops across the parish, several of which were well attended by public meeting standards. But less than 1% of the total population has been heavily involved, and it’s a self-selected group composed mostly of people who believe in public transportation and downtown revitalization. People who fight against so-called smart-growth principles like street connectivity probably didn’t show up, but they could potentially derail the plan’s goals if they choose to do so.
The Center for Planning Excellence funded and conducted public outreach for a recent planning process in Ascension Parish that fell apart when a vocal group of residents “convinced the Planning Commission that no one in the parish wanted the plan,” CPEX President Elizabeth “Boo” Thomas says.
“We would call people we knew had supported this process all along and said, ‘Y’all need to come to these meetings,’ and they would basically say, ‘No, we’re not going to get beat up by those people,’” Thomas says, adding the same thing could happen here, although planning is less controversial in East Baton Rouge, where the law mandates regular plan updates, than in Ascension, which has never had a master plan.
Nothing about FuturEBR is final. What has been shown so far is a summary of the major themes, and residents still have time to comment [visit futurebr.com for more information] before the East Baton Rouge Planning Commission gets involved, most likely in May.
“There’s been a ton of [public] involvement,” Monsour says. “There’s going to be more once we go back out and say, ‘This is what you said you wanted. Here’s what it looks like. Here’s what it’s going to require. Did we get it right?’”
