I have been closely watching the dramatic developments in the capitals of Wisconsin, New Hampshire and Ohio as their lawmakers boldly stare down the screaming mobs of union members and put an end to collective bargaining. It’s about time—and I hope Louisiana will join this list of states.
My experience has mostly been with the teachers unions, who actually don’t have a membership made up solely of active classroom teachers. Did you know that? [I think the union bosses know that, instead of calling them “teamsters” or “employees,” the warm and fuzzy brand of “teachers” has more clout with the politicians and the public, so who cares if many aren’t really teachers.]
I have found that, in education, the unions are there to protect adults and their jobs, not students. If you ever get the chance to watch Waiting for Superman, please do it. [It is available on pay-per-view.] You will see the harm that unions have done to children and our education system. Michelle Rhee, the former superintendent of D.C. schools, offered to increase teacher salaries up to $127,000 a year in exchange for giving up tenure. The unions, who always scream for more money, wouldn’t even allow members to vote.
In Waiting for Superman, Randi Weingarten, the president of the American Federation of Teachers, speaks to a crowd of union members and says, “People claim we represent a special interest group. Well, we do. Our special interest are the children in the classroom.” That is hogwash—or let me say, a flat-out lie. The unions represent the interests of most adults working in the building, on the grounds or driving the buses—period.
Unions and trade guilds have been around since the late 1600s. They had their heyday in the 1950s. In the private sector today, unions are said to be as low a percentage of the workforce as they were in the 1930s and are still on the decline. The public sector, including schools, is their stronghold—but thankfully, we see that may be changing. Unions are about protecting jobs, not about performance.
There were certainly valid reasons for unions being created. But as we saw in the automobile business, they got greedy and became the problem. The same is happening in the public sector where members receive outrageous health benefits and retirement plans that most workers in the private sector do not enjoy—and these workers have no sympathy for the unions if they get cut. And when they hear about tenure—basically a guarantee you can’t be fired even if you are incompetent—then folks get just plain mad. That is not the real world they live in.
State leaders have gotten the message, and the day of reckoning for unions across America is here—and it’s long overdue.
Miracles do happen
Seven years ago, New Orleans had one of the worst school systems in the nation, run by the Orleans Parish School Board. Baton Rouge often made jokes about New Orleans schools. Not anymore.
After Katrina, State Superintendent Paul Pastorek established the RSD [Recovery School District] and hired Paul Vallas to run it. BESE board member Chas Roemer recently described what has transpired for students as “a miracle.” [As he notes, there have been challenges and it’s not perfect, but that is to be expected.]
The RSD represents the country’s most aggressive attempt to systematically transform chronically low-performing schools in the inner city. The nation has watched this experiment, and now, with measurable results in, education leaders are coming to Louisiana for answers.
Gov. Bobby Jindal and Pastorek have stood their ground in defending the purpose of the RSD and Vallas, and new data shows they were right. A recent report, “Louisiana’s Turnaround Zone: Answering the Urgency of Now,” studied the last five years [2004-2009 school years] and found that the number of students attending failing schools in New Orleans has dropped from 68% to just below 18%. That is a miracle.
Instead of acknowledging and celebrating this success, there are many in New Orleans—including legislators—who want to give these schools back to the OPSB. Why would anyone want to do that? I know why the unions and politicians and former employees all want them back: power, money, tenure and jobs. They could give a damn about educating the children or their success.
The rest of the nation is envious of our bold innovation and how far we have come … and many in New Orleans want to go back to the way it was. Are you kidding me? The governor, Mayor Mitch Landrieu, the Legislature and BESE, as well as Louisiana residents, cannot let that happen. Our children deserve to keep their miracle.
Young Heroes
April 20, 2011, is Louisiana Young Heroes Day, and Rotary and WLPB-TV will recognize these inspiring young people for the 15th year in a row. Eight outstanding young men and women from across the state will be honored, 7th-12th graders who have excelled in the classroom, served their community or shown great courage in overcoming adversity.
One of the honorees is Shaela Nelson, 16, a junior at Scotlandville Magnet High School in Baton Rouge. Shaela lost both her parents when she was in middle school and her grandmother in 2010, leaving her in the custody of her older sister. An outstanding student in the Academy of Engineering at Scotlandville Magnet in Baton Rouge, she is a leader in a long list of organizations at the school, including the National Society of Black Engineers, the SMHS MoonBuggy Team and I Care. She also mentors other students through the Girls in Engineering, Math and Science [GEMS] program.
Congratulations to all of the Young Heroes and to Rotary and WLPB for honoring them each year. Our future is in good hands.
Cleo and The Advocate
Politics makes strange bedfellows, and it seems The Advocate editorial writers have found someone who dislikes Gov. Bobby Jindal as much as they do. That would be Cleo Fields.
Recently, they had the audacity to pen an editorial hailing Fields, of all people, for his “moral” argument in court, relating to diversity on boards and commissions. Fields tried to stop the Board of Regents from conducting a study related to the merger of SUNO and UNO in New Orleans.
Isn’t Fields the guy we saw on video stuffing his pockets with cash being handed to him by ex-con Edwin Edwards? Was he being “moral” then?
I wonder—if The Advocate went back and researched, how many people who weren’t black would they find that Fields had recommended for appointments while a state senator?
And let me ask The Advocate, if Jindal decides to appoint five black members to fill new terms on the Southern board this year, do they think Fields will object? Will The Advocate demand diversity? But we don’t even have to be so hypothetical. Did Fields or The Advocate say anything two years ago when Jindal made all black appointments to the Southern board? The Southern University System is a statewide system—and our state is more than 60% white. I certainly don’t recall seeing or hearing a word of protest from Fields or The Advocate. Interesting.
One could expect this shameless behavior and grandstanding from Fields, who I hear is looking to get back into politics. It gets him headlines. But for The Advocate to use their editorial space to hold up Fields as the embodiment of morality—in order to get one more shot at Jindal—just makes their bias against the governor more obvious.
