It was over in an instant.
Tax dollars that could help fund schools, build roads, repair our sewer system or keep an iffy budget scenario in East Baton Rouge Parish from getting worse marched one step closer to being diverted to another cause.
It took all of 10 seconds—and even fewer words—for the Metro Council to clear the path for at least some of that money to instead go to the building of a privately owned downtown hotel. There was no discussion. No debate. Not even a formal vote where council members electronically register their votes. All it took was a simple, “Any objection? Seeing none, the motion passes.”
It happened so fast that the few members of the public who were in the audience to voice their opinions didn’t realize the item was on the clock until it was too late. Usain Bolt couldn’t have sprinted to the podium fast enough to beat the council vote.
Next on the agenda will be the council deciding how much of the hotel and motel tax revenue that this planned hotel generates will be used, in the name of economic development, to pay for the construction of this planned hotel.
Welcome to East Baton Rouge’s love affair with utilizing public dollars to help fund private hotel construction using a vehicle known as Tax Incremental Financing. This will mark the fourth hotel to be built using TIF.
Admittedly, not every penny of the 13-cent hotel tax generated by the planned $17 million Hampton Inn & Suites—slated for construction within the next 60 days at the intersection of Lafayette and Main streets—will be redirected back to its South Carolina-based developers in the name of offsetting construction costs. The state Legislature and the governor, for example, will decide what, if anything, to do with their four cents, which helps fund CATS, the Baton Rouge Sports Foundation, debt service on the expansion of the River Center and—for some crazy reason—the Louisiana Technology Park. The Metro Council decides what happens to the remaining nine cents.
As much as I object to this latest edition of TIF Gone Wild, what’s truly fascinating is how little everyone else in this conservative-leaning parish cares about this stripping of tax dollars in the name of economic development.
The fiscal conservatives and Tea Party members of this parish angrily revolted when sales and property taxes—emphasis on property taxes—were twice proposed to fund the downtown Alive project. Yet it’s sounds of silence from these bastions of government only a Founding Father could love when the issue is the spending of tax dollars to build three downtown hotels, as well as another along the popular development corridor known as Bluebonnet Boulevard.
The people of East Baton Rouge, it seems, have no problem spending public dollars in the name of economic development, provided they think the money isn’t coming directly from their wallets and purses.
They don’t scream, we’re told, about this form of corporate welfare to create bell hop, desk clerk and maid service jobs because 1] only hotel and motel guests, mostly out-of-town folks, pay the tab, and 2] there’s this notion that the tax revenue government is so willing to forgo exists only because of the specific rent-a-room facility.
This second theory hinges on the assumption that the people who occupy these rooms wouldn’t otherwise come to Baton Rouge and stay in one of the scores of existing hotels and motels built without a penny of TIF. Perhaps Loren Scott can do a study determining how many of the guests shelling out $130-plus a night are declaring it’s the Hilton Capitol House—or Hotel Indigo—or bust.
One of the loudest arguments made by opponents of Alive was that government should not involve itself in business that belongs exclusively with the private sector. OK, but how do they then remain silent in suburbia as government explicitly helps these four hotels gain a financial advantage over the other hotels and motels in the parish?
We, as a community, should be thrilled that two historic hotels have opened downtown and that a third hotel is on the drawing board—just as we should applaud Mike Wampold for turning the eyesore that was once going to be a Swaggart campus dorm into a fabulous hotel and meeting center.
That said, just because these projects are good things does not mean government needs to lend a financial hand.
