The police-involved shootings this month in Baton Rouge have touched upon every thread in the fabric of our Louisiana lives. And that includes politics, where the aftershock of the tragedies watched by the nation will continue to play out in the coming elections and future lawmaking sessions of Congress and the state Legislature.
In a recent guest column offered to newspapers around Louisiana, Gov. John Bel Edwards reflected on the “unspeakable loss” suffered by our state. “The answers to all of our questions may never come,” the governor writes, “yet if we are willing to heal together as a community, we will be the better for it.”
Questions will be asked. Candidates, particularly those running in the Capital Region, won’t be able to avoid them. Policymakers on every level are also being charged with finding solutions, and a variety of bills and proposals are coming together.
Two different situations need to be addressed, and they may draw dissimilar political responses. First, there’s the death of Alton Sterling, which resulted in a string of protests with choruses of “Black Lives Matter.” There’s also the subsequent shootings of East Baton Rouge Parish sheriff’s deputy Brad Garafola and Baton Rouge police officers Matthew Gerald and Montrell Jackson, who were killed by Gavin Long.
So far, the aftermath has surfaced most acutely in the 2nd Congressional District, which runs from the heart of New Orleans, where incumbent U.S. Rep. Cedric Richmond lives, and up and around to north Baton Rouge, the home of Mayor Kip Holden. There are two other lesser known candidates running as well, but Richmond and Holden, both Democrats, are the marquee contenders.
You would have thought East Baton Rouge, and not Orleans, had become the 2nd District’s swing parish the way Richmond and Holden accused each other of not properly looking out for Red Stick last week during the qualifying period. Richmond slammed the mayor for his response to the recent shootings and told him to resign. Holden, meanwhile, said Richmond had ignored the Capital Region as a congressman and put Baton Rouge in the “lost and found.”
Richmond has the incumbent’s advantage and the mayor, who lost his bid for lieutenant governor last year, is looking at a steep, uphill climb. At least one community leader has threatened a mayoral recall of Holden, and criticisms about the mayor’s immediate response to the July shootings aren’t going away.
Beyond whether it’ll be a competitive election—and expectations are low—the Richmond-Holden showdown is just one of the places where these national nightmares will continue to have a presence in the coming months.
The race to replace Holden as Baton Rouge’s next mayor will be a host to further fallout as well. But it won’t center on how the candidates responded to the shootings. The discussion will be more about where the city goes from here.
A dozen candidates have jumped into the mayor’s race, and the field is as diverse as the city itself, with five black candidates and seven white candidates. Almost every possible level of interpretation of the shootings will be represented by the contrasting personalities on the ballot. Moreover, frank conversations about race and the segregated geography of the city could lead to some tense moments on the campaign trail.
On the state level, the Louisiana Legislature in 2017 will surely hear a number of related proposals. During this year’s regular session, GOP Rep. Lance Harris, of Alexandria, passed his “Blue Lives Matter” law making it a hate crime to target police and first responders. It wasn’t in effect this month when the unimaginable struck, but it probably would have been applicable in Baton Rouge had it been.
Meanwhile on the Hill, Republican U.S. Rep. Garret Graves of Baton Rouge and Richmond, a Democrat, have introduced legislation in response to the officer-involved shootings. Their bipartisan bill offers state and local law enforcement officers voluntary access to new nonlethal technologies to help protect the public.
Simply put, money is needed, too. Graves said the total cost of responding to the recent shootings could reach anywhere between $3 million and $5 million. These costs are incurred by the Baton Rouge Police Department, East Baton Rouge Parish Sheriff’s Office and Louisiana State Police, as well as other law enforcement agencies and first responders.
The fear is that these increased costs will come at the expense of future training, weapons and other capabilities. There is already some movement on that front, with Graves announcing last week $650,000 in federal assistance from the U.S. Justice Department.
Edwards was right about one thing. We may not get all of the answers we’re looking for when it comes to this overheated summer in Baton Rouge—even from our government and politicians. But figuring out how to lead the city and state through the next elected terms, coming up with ways to avoid the same thing happening in the future, and talking about it in forums on the community level are all viable paths towards healing. That is probably what the state needs right now more than anything else.
Jeremy Alford publishes LaPolitics Weekly, a newsletter on Louisiana politics at LaPolitics.com. Follow him on Twitter, or on Facebook. He can be reached at JJA@LaPolitics.com.
