For Cathy Gautreaux, one of the worst aspects of last year’s legislative fight over an anti-indemnity bill was that it pitted typically amicable groups against each other.
Gautreaux is executive director of the Louisiana Motor Transport Association, which she says joined other business interests in the late 1980s to back tort reform. The battle lines were familiar, with business on one side and trial lawyers on the other. The guiding principle behind tort reform is that the responsible party should pay damages, she says, regardless of who has the deepest pockets.
“Whoever was negligent paid,” Gautreaux says. “This is the same premise.”
“This” is Act 492, which regulates contracts between companies—chemical manufacturers, for example—and their trucking or construction contractors. The law prohibits those contracts from including clauses that require one party—the contractor—to shield the other party from liability through what’s often called an indemnity or “hold harmless” clause. Supporters say the law is fair: We keep our negligence; you keep yours. To detractors, it’s an unconscionable and possibly unconstitutional intrusion by the Legislature into contracts between consenting parties.
“They said, ‘If you’re going to work in my plant and an accident happens and you’re engaged in it, we’re not going to argue about how much of it was my responsibility and how much of it was your responsibility,’” says Cajun Industries founder Lane Grigsby, describing how things worked before the anti-indemnity law.
“The contractor had a simple choice: If you wanted to work in the plant, and you measured that risk and decided it was worth it for the profit you could make, you would sign the contract. If you decided you didn’t like the terms and conditions, you didn’t have to sign the contract. No one put a gun to your head.”
The Louisiana Chemical Association has sued to overturn the law, saying it violates the state and/or U.S. constitutions by impairing the obligations of existing contracts, subjecting some businesses to the act but not others, isolating Louisiana contracts from the national economy and lacking a rational relationship to a legitimate state interest. LCA declined to comment, but people who also oppose the law emphasize what they see as a basic American value over legal technicalities.
“The terms and conditions between private parties within private contracts should be negotiated by, and only by, the private contracting parties, and not by the Legislature,” says John Walters, vice president of governmental relations with Associated Builders and Contractors, Pelican Chapter.
The transport association agrees that in a perfect world, equal parties should be able to contract at will. But the world is not perfect, and parties frequently are far from equal.
Chemical companies and other large corporations have the upper hand over small trucking companies that need work and don’t have their own legal teams to negotiate contracts, the association argues. In a sluggish economy, a trucker is going to feel pressured to take the job and swallow the risk. It notes that government sometimes steps in to ensure fairness by breaking up a monopoly, for example, and Louisiana has had an oilfield anti-indemnity law since 1981. So why is this different?
Many big oil and chemical companies are fair, Gautreaux says, adding that some of their representatives concede privately that perhaps the law should have been tweaked. But she says a contingent said, “Not no, but hell no,” and suggests that arrogance might have backfired and helped the law pass.
Gautreaux was disappointed, but not surprised, that the Baton Rouge Area Chamber opposed the bill, given the makeup of its board. Mike Odom, BRAC’s senior vice president of marketing, didn’t respond to an e-mail seeking comment.
“It was the ugliest piece of legislation I’ve ever been involved with or witnessed,” Gautreaux says, claiming that companies were threatened with the loss of contracts if they supported the bill. She warned her members to stay away from the State Capitol.
“If I never have to go through another fight like that, I’ll feel blessed,” she says. “Hopefully time will heal those wounds.”
Twenty-six states, including Louisiana, have passed anti-indemnity laws for motor carrier contracts, many in the past few years, and several others are considering doing the same, the transport association says. Jeff Albright, CEO of the Independent Insurance Agents & Brokers of Louisiana, says 35 states have passed some sort of anti-indemnity legislation.
A similar bill pertaining only to trucking died in 2008. This time, Grigsby says, building contractors were included, which split the opposition and helped the legislation pass. He staunchly opposed the law, and says he might work to overturn it in a future session if the courts don’t throw it out.
Walters says he’s unsure what impact the law will have. Even if it’s upheld, he says, the courts will have to interpret how it’s applied. He’s heard that company owners might require contractors to have more insurance to work in one of their facilities, putting smaller contractors at a competitive disadvantage.
“They’re going to require whatever insurance they think is necessary to cover the liability,” says Albright, whose organization supported the law. “If anything, the insurance requirements ought to go down, because in the past they were forcing the subcontractor to insure the subcontractor’s liability and cover the chemical plant’s liability. Now there is less risk to the subcontractor. Why would they require more insurance? That sounds to me like a plain, bald threat.”
He says insurance companies have enough liability when they insure their own customers without taking on extra exposure that other entities try to transfer to their customers.
Grigsby says the law could end up benefiting contractors with poor safety records, who were paying high insurance rates or had difficulty obtaining insurance at all. “People who don’t have a good safety record ought to pay a price for that behavior.”
