We can all look back with regret at decisions we’ve made and opportunities we’ve missed. The big misses can be costly and painful. Sometimes, there’s an impulse to defend ourselves and say “hindsight is 20-20,” instead of just admitting we messed up—and learning from those disappointments. Hopefully, we learn to be open to new ideas and “think outside the box” when big decisions come along—and to get wise counsel. But I want to look at two examples of big misses in our community where we needed to evaluate talent wisely and simply take some risk.
I write this column because, in the near future, our community will have key leadership positions in transition, and we should all pay close attention. As you see below, such decisions have consequences that will impact our community and our children.
Buzzy Thibodeaux
Last week, in honor of Financial Literacy Month, a group of young students involved with Junior Achievement’s financial literacy education program visited the New York Stock Exchange on Wall Street. There with them to ring the closing bell was Baton Rouge’s own Buzzy Thibodeaux, executive vice president of Junior Achievement USA.
Thibodeaux now holds the No. 2 post in the organization. In this job, he provides leadership on national issues, with particular focus on strengthening JA’s relationships on Capitol Hill for promoting the issues of financial literacy, work-readiness and entrepreneurship education for young people.
Thibodeaux, who had built the Baton Rouge office of Junior Achievement into one of the fastest growing in the country, has always been a creative thinker who dreams big. In 1994, he was recognized as one of Baton Rouge’s “Forty Under 40.” Thibodeaux saw great potential in the Capital City and was a huge Tiger fan. His passion led him to apply for an open position as head of the Baton Rouge Convention & Visitors Bureau back in the mid-’90s. Unfortunately, following a Baton Rouge tradition, the board of the CVB played it safe and went with a traditional hire from a CVB in a smaller market.
The board was controlled by hotel folks who were just interested in someone who understood “heads on beds”—not someone with a bigger vision for Baton Rouge. It was thinking small, a problem that has held us back too often.
Thibodeaux was not an old line “tourism guy,” and the board couldn’t see past that. One member, Bill Michelet, complained that Thibodeaux didn’t meet the job requirements for executive director, which called for experience in the convention and visitors bureau industry. Well, Bill got his way, and how did that work out? [Do you remember “Bon Flop”?]
The CVB—and Baton Rouge—missed a golden opportunity, sort of like those NFL teams years ago who skipped over Tom Brady for the first 198 picks in the draft. They blew it. They couldn’t spot talent and “think out of the box.”
Soon after the CVB search ended, the national office of JA came calling and hired Thibodeaux away to Colorado Springs, where their national headquarters is located. He soon became vice president over marketing, then took on public affairs on Capitol Hill, and eventually rose to his current spot as No. 2.
Junior Achievement is worldwide and reaches 9.7 million students in 122 countries with 330,000 classroom volunteers. The headquarters has an operating budget of $32 million and JA offices around the world raise $266 million in local funding.
Thibodeaux travels a lot in his job, and he was given the choice to live wherever he would like. He chose to move back to Baton Rouge, just because he loves this place [and loves his LSU Tigers]. I am glad he’s back.
You know, the slogan for Junior Achievement is “Empowering young people to own their economic success.” Fact is, our city missed the opportunity to have this very talented leader empower Baton Rouge for economic success.
Scott Shirey
In 2010, Arkansas Business magazine named its “Best & Brightest,” and there on the list was Scott Shirey, 34, executive director of KIPP Delta Public School.
In the article, Shirey says, “We have an expression at KIPP that the actual proves the possible. We just had a graduation with 23 seniors and all of them are headed to college, and that’s, at any measure, the No. 1 accomplishment.”
That is amazing when you think of the poor, minority children that KIPP serves. What would the East Baton Rouge public school system do to have a school like that? Let me tell you.
Shirey begged to share his talents with the children and parents in Baton Rouge in 2001, and our school board said, “No.” So he left for Arkansas—which was recruiting him—and you see his results. That could have been us.
Shirey, who was with Teach for America, had been an outstanding teacher at Southeast Middle School. Before a school board committee meeting to consider a KIPP charter school in EBR, he told The Advocate, “Right now my primary concern is with Baton Rouge because I really feel that over the last three years, I felt some sense of belonging, a sense of community. It’s where my priority is. It’s where my heart is.”
But Brooks Flemister, a KIPP leader in Houston, was pessimistic, telling The Advocate, “I’m not holding my breath with the committee and the board. There were strong anti-charter statements by the board.” He was right. The culprits I remember were Noel Hammatt, Jackie Mims, Pat Smith and Patrice Niquille. And they ran Shirey and KIPP out of town.
The Advocate penned an editorial after Shirey left Baton Rouge in 2001. It said, “Perhaps we are fortunate in East Baton Rouge Parish to have a School Board of such exquisite discernment that members can spot without hesitation a bad idea, one that seemingly everyone else in America believes to be a terrific model for public school reform.
“Board members chased off the organizers of the proposed charter school, a KIPP academy, despite its sterling reputation. In New York City and in Houston, the first two charter schools organized by the Knowledge Is Power Program have won academic accolades.” It goes on to say, “But the eagle eyes of Noel Hammatt and Jackie Mims know better. … They made such negative comments about the idea of approving a new charter school that the KIPP organizers withdrew their application for a local charter.”
KIPP did return to Louisiana in 2005 to apply for a charter in New Orleans. The approval by BESE gave The Advocate another opportunity to editorialize. They wrote, “If the KIPP academy is a coup for New Orleans, it’s a shame that it’s the first KIPP school in Louisiana. We say that because Baton Rouge had an opportunity to get a KIPP school, in 2001, when a talented young teacher proposed the idea.
Since 2005, KIPP has opened six schools in New Orleans covering K-12, and several of them are among the highest-performing open enrollment schools in the city.
The appalling action in 2001 by the school board has impacted poor children in our community for a decade—some of whom might have dropped out by now. The status quo won the battle—and our community lost.
I hope our community and the new EBR School Board members will take note of this disgraceful history and lack of vision and realize what was lost over the past decade. How many more children need lose their future?
