La. gets top ranking for pro-student education policies

StudentsFirst—an advocacy group promoting education reform through teacher tenure overhauls, introducing the use of standardized test scores in performance evaluations, and charter school expansion—places Louisiana at the top a new ranking for states implementing such policies. Both Louisiana and Florida received a “B-” grade in the ranking, with no states receiving a higher grade. However, Louisiana is ranked No. 1 overall in the report, just ahead of Florida. Twelve states received an “F” grade in the report, reflecting StudentsFirst’s willingness to build a reputation as a harsh grader. The ratings focus purely on state laws and policies, and do not take into account student test scores. “This report confirms that Louisiana is now leading the nation in education reform because of our commitment to put a great teacher in every classroom and give every child the opportunity to get a great education,” says Gov. Bobby Jindal in a prepared response to the rankings. “Our reforms are working—parents finally have more choices, student scores are up, and teachers are being rewarded for their hard work.” Michelle Rhee, leader of StudentsFirst and former chancellor of Washington, D.C., public schools, tells The New York Times the relatively weak state grades in the report reflect how recently statehouses have begun to address issues such as teacher tenure and performance evaluations. Louisiana’s overall grade was derived from several components; the state received an “A” for elevating teaching, a “C” for empowering parents, and a “C-” for spending wisely and governing well. The report card says Louisiana must strengthen its accountability framework for all public charter schools and ensure students attending private schools through public scholarships are meeting academic goals. It adds that teachers could be offered the portable, cash-balance retirement option that is available to other state employees.