Higher ed model must change to compete

Author Profile Image
Sign up for the free Daily Report email – local news about the people, companies and issues that impact business impact business in Baton Rouge and beyond.

I want to share some interesting facts and predictions from a recent column by Forbes Editor-in-Chief Steve Forbes titled “Dinosaur U.” He forecasts that the Internet—along with DVDs, institutions in China and India, for-profit colleges, and pressure from demanding parents paying higher tuitions—will “profoundly upend” America’s universities and colleges in the future. He also suggests it will improve them.

He argues that the Internet has already done it to media and entertainment and that higher education will be the next victim. [I hope K-12 education will soon begin to see the same effects, too.] No person or institution will be untouched by the innovation of the Internet. Accept the fact.

Forbes wrote, “While our most prestigious institutions will continue to have countless more applicants than places, other colleges and universities will face increasingly more difficult times. Many won’t make it. As the late Peter Drucker presciently said before the end of the last century: ‘Thirty years from now the big university campuses will be relics.’ ”

Advertisement

There are many contributing factors [or competitors], as noted above. In addition, Forbes points to comments made by Louis Lataif, dean emeritus of Boston University School of Management and a former president of Ford Europe. Lataif says that rising tuition is a bubble about to burst. Lataif wrote in a recent column on Forbes.com, “In the last 30 years overall inflation in the U.S. was 106%; health care costs went up 251%. College tuitions and fees? They soared 439%. The basic business model of higher education in the U.S. is broken.” Lataif says one of the reasons is the federal government and increasing aid—which perverts the markets.

Likewise, here in Louisiana, we will not be able to fund at satisfactory levels all our colleges and universities year after year—especially those with very low success and graduation rates. And only those that provide the value and a marketable degree are going to be able to attract students and justify their tuition—if federal and state government support is finally limited. And it will be, soon. When it’s their money being spent, students and parents will choose more wisely, and mediocrity is a loser in the market.

There are those who will argue that without federal aid many could not go to college. But is a campus required for a college education these days? Lataif says, “Nearly 30% of all higher education students [are] enrolled in at least one online class.”

He also points out a student can “buy a self-paced calculus course on DVD for $67.” Forbes states, “There’s the startling fact that people retain more information via the Internet or DVDs than they do when sitting in a classroom.”

So maybe the government offers to pay for online courses or DVDs—which would cost much less than classroom interaction. Or what if the government just did an RFP to all universities and let them bid on running a national “Internet U.” The winning bidder would get funding to provide all the courses needed to graduate online for free to every student, with open enrollment. The enrollment at “Internet U” could be millions. We could provide each student with a computer, iPad and Internet connection for four years. We would make college available to everyone, everywhere, and save billions. Think about it. We could even generate revenue by charging tuition to non–U.S. citizens around the world who wanted to study online.

It wouldn’t be the right college experience for everyone, and it wouldn’t mean the mutual learning of the classroom is worthless. But we need to acknowledge it’s not “your daddy’s college” anymore.

Because, as Forbes points out, dinosaurs became extinct.

Hanging on to the past

It is a bit ironic that black leaders in our state want to hang on to part of the past, SUNO, which symbolizes a time when there were few choices for black students wanting to go to college. It wasn’t a particularly pleasant time in history and it is not even a point of pride. In fact, The Times-Picayune reported that SUNO’s graduation rate of 8% [up now from 5%] is the nation’s lowest for any historically black public college. It’s at the bottom in Louisiana and the bottom nationally. So why do so many black leaders oppose a possible merger with UNO, just one mile away?

The staunch defense of SUNO from the black caucus in the Legislature, former New Orleans Mayor Marc Morial, NAACP and Southern System President Ron Mason Jr.—when the facts scream that this patient is on life support—damages their credibility in a serious debate on the future of higher ed. They are basically saying, damn the facts, we are going to defend our turf and the jobs, power and money that go with it. Even if it’s a failing university, it’s our failing university.

Well, many black students don’t seem to see Southern as “their university” anymore. Just look at the enrollments. SUNO doesn’t have many more students than a large metropolitan high school. And the main Southern campus here in Baton Rouge has about 7,300 students, down from 9,500 in 2000. When asked about the decline, a friend explained that the history, allure and pride that many older African-Americans see in the historic black colleges and universities aren’t perceived as much by the younger people. They want to go where they want to go—and don’t feel an obligation when many other options exists. That is the marketplace, and it’s tough to overcome. But we all have to deal with reality and live in the present, not the past.

This proposal to study a merger has brought out ghosts from the past. Morial called the idea “a backward step.” No, Mayor, it’s a forward step so we don’t go backwards. Another ghost from our past who showed up was former Congressman Cleo Fields. He went to court on behalf of SUNO students and sued Gov. Bobby Jindal and the Board of Regents, getting a restraining order from Judge Janice Clark to stop them from studying the merger idea.

Fine. In my opinion, the governor and Regents don’t even need to waste any time studying this issue—just look at the facts that have already been reported. SUNO deserves to be shut down now. It’s a waste of taxpayers’ money and of students’ time and money. Let’s get real here. If one can’t make the case now to merge SUNO, based on its record, then when? If the Regents, Legislature and governor don’t have the political will to merge it with UNO now, I have to wonder if things will ever change in our higher ed structure.

Let’s get this merger accomplished, then move on to a single governing board.

Watch out for the past

There’s a big battle at the Port of Greater Baton Rouge as the lease for a grain elevator is up for grabs. There are some old-time players involved. Cargill Inc. has had the lease for 55 years and wants to renew. But many of the farmers are not happy with Cargill’s past record, prices or service. They contend this site gets little attention because Cargill has two newer elevators it operates downriver.

The new bidder on the scene is Louis Dreyfus Global. The Port Commission had a five-hour meeting to discuss the bidders but held off making a decision because the governor’s office asked that an economic impact study be done by the LSU AgCenter first.

The other old actor everyone better keep an eye on is Larry Johnson, recently elected commission chairman. How he got back in that seat is a mystery to me, but I have my suspicions. He’s been on the commission 19 years. I don’t trust him, and I hope his fellow commissioners have the courage to make the right decision and tell Johnson to stay out of their way.

Discussion (0)

From Our Partners

Daily Report Poll

ASK AI

Ask anything about Baton Rouge business