The Bureau of Labor Statistics released its first in-depth look at nontraditional work since 2005 on Thursday, and came to a startling conclusion: The old-fashioned job remains king.
Roughly 10% of American workers in 2017 were employed in some form of what the government calls “alternative work arrangements,” a category that includes Uber drivers, freelance writers and people employed through temporary-help agencies—anyone whose main source of work comes outside a traditional employment relationship, The New York Times reports.
Far from a boom in gig work, that represents a slight decline from 2005, when about 11% of workers fell into those categories.
The government’s numbers don’t include people who do gig or freelance work in addition to traditional jobs, and separate data released by the Federal Reserve this month found that nearly a third of adults engaged in some form of gig work, either as a primary job or to supplement other sources of income.
The bureau’s data also doesn’t reflect other changes in the last decade plus that left American workers with less security and fewer opportunities for advancement. The report on Thursday also did not break out online workers but a follow-up report scheduled for September will.
The largest category of alternative workers, independent contractors, are disproportionately in their mid-40s or older and common in sectors like construction that have not been disrupted by Silicon Valley entrepreneurs. They earn about as much, on average, as standard employees, and are relatively happy with their arrangements: Nearly 80% say they prefer being an independent contractor to being an employee.
The picture looks different for on-call and temporary workers, who tend to be younger, earn less and rarely have access to employer-provided health or retirement benefits. They are also far more likely to say they would prefer traditional work.
Neither category, however, has grown as a share of the workforce since 2005.
