Prominent real estate attorney Charles Landry explained during a lengthy 2009 interview that a wave of commercial real estate foreclosures could be imminent. Even properties that were performing well, he said, could be in trouble.
His fear was that loans would come due, but project owners would have no way to refinance. The secondary market for loans had vaporized overnight, and many lenders had more real estate deals on their books than they wanted.
“There isn’t the ability to find someone to refinance,” Landry said. “The lenders won’t be able to renew the loan, and the borrowers will have nowhere to go.”
But a year and a half later, the worst fears of Landry and many other real estate professionals have not come true, at least not in the Capital Region. In part, that’s because the area has been protected by its relatively strong economy.
Though it’s still difficult to receive financing from traditional banks, there have been recent indications that some wealthy individuals and investment groups are ready to come off the sidelines and into solid, occupied projects.
Landry, however, doesn’t sound relieved. He says federal regulators are going into local and regional banks, looking at real estate loans—including performing loans—that are up for renewal, and requiring new appraisals. And in this economy, appraised values might be one-third lower than just a few years ago. Some properties have changed hands at distressed prices that might not have reflected the real value, which in turn drags down appraisals for other properties.
Landry says banks are being pressured to do one of two things: either move the loans out of the bank by making borrowers refinance elsewhere—something that’s still very difficult for many borrowers to do—or ask for a significant cash infusion to pay down the principal, maybe 15% to 25% of the loan value, all at once. Again, no easy task for a borrower.
“The apple cart is getting ready to be disrupted by the federal government,” Landry says. “It’ll be interesting to see how this plays out.”
In February, the Congressional Oversight Panel of the Troubled Asset Relief Program heard testimony that about $1.4 trillion in commercial real estate debt is set to mature through 2013. An analyst said as much as half of the maturing mortgages are underwater, with the greatest concentration of such mortgages held by banks with assets between $1 billion and $10 billion.
In March, two legislators, one from California and one from Nevada—states hard hit by the residential meltdown—reintroduced a bill that would jump-start commercial investment by offering tax incentives to new investors.
Betsy Laird, a senior vice president with the International Council of Shopping Centers, calls the bill “a temporary and targeted solution” that would help property owners adjust their loan structures and free up capital to help the economy. A little flexibility might do the trick, Landry says, at least with performing properties.
“Right now, what we need throughout the country is some relief from the banking regulators,” he says, “where they’re not putting so much pressure on the banks that have existing loans.”
Not everyone is pointing fingers at the regulators. Investar Bank CEO John D’Angelo says his lenders still are looking at real estate deals, albeit very selectively. Owner-occupied properties have the best shot, and an owner’s “global cash flow”—as opposed to the cash flow of the single project in question—carries more weight than in the past.
“We certainly listen to examiners,” he says. “But we need to run the bank in the way we think makes the most sense.”
For example, history shows that nonowner-occupied properties are more likely to have credit-quality issues, and Investar is acting accordingly.
“It’s always easy to say it’s the examiners,” D’Angelo says. “I don’t buy into that.”
Lower appraisals are necessitating that borrowers shore up their collateral or reduce the principal, D’Angelo says, adding that it’s not as big a deal as many people feared in 2009. Some people say lenders are simply letting borrowers slide a little, with expectations of changes later when the economy picks up. It’s a practice sometimes called “extend and pretend,” but not by D’Angelo.
“We certainly don’t do that because there’s no future in it,” he says. “A problem’s a problem, and you’re better off addressing it.”
As for the secondary market, D’Angelo says he hears of borrowers talking to big lenders such as insurance companies, but he seldom sees anything come of it. He’s also heard that some government agencies, including the Department of Housing and Urban Development, are moving credit and getting people out of certain deals.
Bigger markets, with massive projects funded by national lenders, have seen issues with foreclosures as occupancy rates have plummeted. For example, the owner of a 200,000-square-foot office building in Chicago could be in trouble when his or her loan matures.
“We just don’t have a lot of those properties in Baton Rouge,” developer Donnie Jarreau says. “Most of the larger properties are owned by the businesses or the local investors.”
Some larger property owners could be facing maturing loans or balloon payments, but lenders are hesitant to call in the loan and take the property, Jarreau says, in part because bankers prefer to be in the business of loaning money, not managing real estate.
“The owner of the property has a better chance of managing and bringing the value up on that property and eventually getting it refinanced,” he says.
Refinancing is very tough, and a 65% to 75% loan-to-value ratio remains the best deal that most borrowers can hope for. Still, things are better today than one year ago, Jarreau says, and the secondary market is slowly loosening up and starting to look for deals.
“For a bank to make money,” he says, “it’s got to yield a return.”
