When Hancock and Whitney banks, two of the Gulf Coast’s oldest and largest financial institutions, announced a $1.5 billion stock-for-stock merger just days before Christmas, Hancock President/CEO Carl Chaney says it completed a deal that first started being pieced together a century ago.
“This merger really started back about 100 years ago, when Hancock Bank was formed in Bay St. Louis and Whitney Bank was formed in New Orleans,” Chaney says. “The banks have always had very similar cultures, and the only thing that really divided them was the state line. My predecessor talked about a merger. So did his.”
While executives might have speculated for decades, Chaney says, discussions of a merger never became serious until last summer, when Hancock was evaluating its December 2009 purchase of Florida-based Peoples First Community Bank from the FDIC for about $2 billion. Hancock executives, feeling good about the integration of its 29 branches, began looking more seriously at acquiring active banks to further expand its southern footprint, Chaney says.
“We’d identified a list of banks that, if they’d ever become available, we’d be very interested in talking with,” he says. “Whitney, of course, was one of them. After watching and knowing them for over 100 years, we finally decided to go ahead and reach out to them about six months ago.”
Chaney called Whitney CEO and board Chairman John Hope III; the men have known each other for years, Chaney says, but they’d never previously talked about a merger. Once the dialogue was opened, however, negotiations moved relatively quickly. Board members from the banks recognized how the two institutions could strengthen through a merger.
“The transaction just made so much sense,” Chaney says, given the “different banking models. They’ve focused more on the commercial lending arena, and we’ve traditionally been more of a retail bank. They really compliment each other.”
Peter Ricchiuti, assistant dean at Tulane University’s Freeman School of Business, says the merger likely will prove a good move for the banks.
“Besides this thing being announced at Christmas and some analysts saying the price was a little high, there wasn’t anything particularly surprising about it,” he says. “I’d always thought these two banks would compliment each other, and I think you’ll really see them join forces and become a much stronger, super-regional bank. This is going to make them a real player.”
Whitney, historically known for being very conservative, got into some financial trouble after expanding into the Florida market during the real estate boom. To ease the burden of bad loans, Whitney took $300 million from the federal Troubled Asset Relief Program in 2008. Hancock, which didn’t take TARP funds, will pay back all the bailout funds owed as soon as the transaction gets regulatory approval, which is expected by the end of the second quarter.
Chaney says the TARP money Whitney owed did not weaken the bank and did not factor into its decision to merge with Hancock, which in December 2009 was named one of the strongest and safest banks by BauerFinancial for the 20th straight year. The honor recognized Hancock’s commitment to conservative business practices, proactive risk management and corporate values.
“The real driver was, Whitney saw an opportunity to partner up with a company that is very strong, very stable, has a similar culture and intends to grow in the Gulf South market,” Chaney says.
While the banks’ long histories helped complete the merger, Chaney says, they also posed the biggest obstacle.
“When you have a company that’s 127 years old, as Whitney is, there’s a lot of pride built up in that brand name. No organization wants to see that go away,” he says. “If we had been a new bank, it would have been much more difficult for them to get comfortable with the idea of merging with us.”
Although negotiations never hinged on the combined name, Chaney says it only makes sense to capitalize on the strength of the Whitney brand. All banks in Louisiana and Texas will become Whitney banks, and the Hancock brand will be used in Mississippi, Alabama and Florida.
The merger is the largest in Hancock’s history, and the bank now ranks No. 32 nationally in total deposits. The deal also more than doubles its number of branches to more than 300, ATMs to more than 400 and employees to more than 5,000.
Hancock had 8% market share in the Baton Rouge area before the merger’s announcement, with 20 branches in the parish and additional locations in Baker, Denham Springs, Gonzales, Walker and Zachary. Whitney had 15 branches in the area and a little more than 5% of the market share, according to the FDIC.
“As far as mergers go, I cannot imagine another bank that’s more perfect for Hancock than Whitney,” Chaney says. “You just don’t see a lot of deals, in any industry, that make as much sense as this one did.”
