If it were up to East Baton Rouge Planning Director Frank Duke, he might just scrap the city-parish’s rural cluster subdivision development ordinance as it is written.
“The ordinance we’re dealing with now, I don’t think it works,” the planning director says.
The cluster subdivision ordinance, which is slightly more than two pages in the city-parish Code of Ordinances, allows for developers to build to the density of one unit per acre, but cluster the homes to a certain part of the property at roughly four homes per acre while leaving the rest as undevelopable property.
Duke says one of his biggest gripes with the ordinance as it’s written is that the environmental value of the land not being developed is not considered. For example, the ordinance doesn’t differentiate whether the land is archaeologically significant. It also does not account for floodplains that should not be developed, wetlands that cannot be developed, or a forest of live oak trees providing significant habitat. It is all treated the same and given the same density rate.
“Right now, that’s one of the problems,” he says.
The ordinance is one of several rural zoning ordinances under review by a subcommittee of the Zoning Advisory Committee at the behest of Metro Councilman Buddy Amoroso. The subcommittee met last week and is scheduled to meet next week.
The cluster subdivision ordinance has been in the spotlight for the past few months as the Planning Commission debated and then ultimately voted down a request Monday by developer Arthur Lancaster to build his proposed Timber Ridge subdivision.
Plans for the subdivision included 281 homes on 68.5 acres of a 281-acre tract and leaving the remaining 212.5 acres—along with 198.5 acres on an adjacent tract—as undevelopable land.
The ordinance has drawn the ire of Duke, who has said multiple times that he feels it needs to be rewritten, and Planning Commission member John Price.
“I think we have a significant problem with a cluster subdivision as it’s defined and used in our Unified Development Code,” Price told the Planning Commission board and attendees at Monday’s meeting. “It continues to come back to haunt us.”
Duke adds he has several other issues with the cluster subdivision ordinance and could spend several days dissecting it and pulling out every problem.
Duke has been asked if he could find another city’s cluster ordinance that he likes and copy it to use in Baton Rouge. That’s not feasible because all cities are different, he tells Daily Report.
Duke cannot say when the changes will be finalized by the subcommittee of the Zoning Advisory Committee because it is a lengthy process of crafting concepts for the ordinances, drafting the language for each ordinance and then going back to the subcommittee to look at the language.
“It is moving forward,” Duke says.
—Ryan Broussard
