Care package

Author Profile Image
Sign up for the free Daily Report email – local news about the people, companies and issues that impact business impact business in Baton Rouge and beyond.

Gov. Bobby Jindal’s top health care official had hoped to use an emergency rule process to speed approval of the state’s latest plan to reform Medicaid. Then health care providers protested, claiming the change was being pushed through without enough debate, and the administration quickly backed down.

A chastened Bruce Greenstein, secretary of the Department of Health and Hospitals, appeared before a skeptical state Senate panel in October, promising to slow down and listen to critics of the plan.

“So will you be giving us a head’s up on when you will file this notice of intent?” asked Sen. Sherri Smith Cheek, a Keithville Republican. Greenstein assured her that he would.

Advertisement

“I might not be the best student in the class, but I certainly learned my lesson,” he said, eliciting laughter from some people in the room but only a wry smile from Cheek.

“That would certainly help to foster a better relationship,” she said.

According to Greenstein, the state still pays for health care for the poor in the way it has since the 1960s: A doctor provides a service and bills the state, which sends back a reimbursement check. The system rewards volume, not quality, of care.

From the state’s perspective, the current system costs too much and delivers unacceptable results. Providers complain Medicaid doesn’t reimburse them fairly, forcing them to shift costs to paying customers.

“Those costs are passed along to the consumers,” says Dr. Steven Spedale, a pediatrician who serves as chair of the physicians group MedicineLouisiana. “Nobody even tries to hide that fact anymore.”

DHH wants to create coordinated care networks that would allow private insurance companies to accept Medicaid payments to deliver managed care for the poor, saving the state money and producing better results. MedicineLouisiana is one of several provider groups that pushed back against the plan.

The United Health Foundation says Louisiana ranks No. 49 among states for overall health. The assessment was announced Dec. 7, just as DHH was about to begin a series of nine forums across the state on Medicaid reform.

“The rank of 49 should be a wake-up call to everyone in the state,” Greenstein says, “particularly those who are fighting to protect the status quo.”

States that top the list, and the ones that show the most improvement, he says, use a coordinated care strategy for Medicaid patients. Compared to other states, he says, Louisiana is an outlier in several areas managed care is good at controlling, including avoidable hospitalizations, overusing emergency services, and using too many specialists and not enough primary care doctors.

But providers worry CCNs would divert funds that should go to care into insurance companies’ profits. And while Greenstein defends the core of the state’s strategy, he’s made several concessions since October. He now plans to issue a request for proposals from insurance companies before they would be allowed to participate, rather than letting in any company that meets minimum standards, an approach one critic says would have led to chaos.

DHH says it will make current Medicaid reimbursement rates the absolute floor under the new system, a nod to providers who say they’ve already suffered $250 million in cuts over the past two years, and will include in the agreement medical-loss ratios, which would require the insurers to spend a minimum amount on actual care. Participating companies would be subject to a prompt payment requirement.

And the state also plans a shared savings option, in which a third party could form a coalition of providers to care for Medicaid patients and share any savings. While this side of the CCN strategy has not been as widely discussed, DHH says it always has been part of the plan.

David Hood, a former DHH secretary who works on health care policy for the Public Affairs Research Council, has been critical of the state’s approach. He says he’s pleased with the decision to have an RFP, and he hopes the medical-loss ratio is enforced at a minimum level of 85%.

But Hood still believes there are better ways to go. He supports a gradual shift to the so-called North Carolina model, in which physician-led networks manage care in partnership with the state, without the insurance company middleman. North Carolina’s approach has been imitated by several other states. Hood says Louisiana’s existing CommunityCARE program, which connects Medicaid recipients with a primary care provider, could be the starting point for the shift he suggests.

Spedale also prefers the North Carolina model. He agrees change is necessary, but he worries about relying on outside companies that might come and go over providers that will be around for years.

“We think we need to do it ourselves,” he says.

Nick Simmons, an actuary with Mercer Government Human Services Consulting, says DHH doesn’t have the time, resources and competency to develop such a system, and says North Carolina has about 500 quasi-public employees who work for the networks.

“You outsource stuff that you’re not good at,” he says, adding that the DHH plan Mercer helped create could save at least 3.5% in the first year.

During last year’s legislative session, Greenstein says DHH and lawmakers envisioned getting CCNs off the ground by April, partly to take advantage of potential savings during the current budget year that ends in June. DHH now hopes to get the program running by the end of the year.

John Matessino, director of the Louisiana Hospital Association, says providers were left out of the discussion prior to issuance of the emergency rule. Greenstein says there were numerous meetings with stakeholders; he doesn’t mind having more, but he doesn’t intend to start from scratch. At some point, the state will have to cut off debate and move forward.

“Change is not easy,” he says. “There are very few things that people get more exercised over [than health care].”

State officials have been talking about managed care since Jindal served as DHH secretary, but Louisiana remains one of only a few states that doesn’t use some form of that approach. Greenstein suggests providers might not have raised their objections until October because they thought managed care wouldn’t happen. Critics say state officials in past meetings seemed to listen to objections without wavering from what they wanted to do.

Matessino says DHH implies its critics are simply defending the status quo. But he says the hospital association and other stakeholder groups are working on their own plan, which would be similar to the shared savings model and could be implemented alongside the CCNs. He expects to go public with the plan this month.

Discussion (0)

From Our Partners

Daily Report Poll

ASK AI

Ask anything about Baton Rouge business