The Louisiana Legislature has done a poor job of keeping pace with the ever-changing world of campaign finance. That’s especially true when it comes to super PACs, which are political action committees that are allowed to raise unlimited amounts of money thanks to a 2010 U.S. Supreme Court decision. Super PACs can be used for various purposes, but more times than not they spend money on either supporting or attacking candidates.
In defense of the Legislature, this is somewhat of a new trend in Louisiana and last year’s race for governor was the first time super PACs ever played a role on the state level. Of course, we had seen them spend money here on congressional and national races that pre-dated 2015, but those instances fell under the jurisdiction of the Federal Election Commission.
Today, however, there’s enough overlap between super PACs and state campaign finance accounts that lawmakers should begin taking steps to increase transparency and strengthen reporting requirements. There’s no reason why this topic should not be on the agendas of the House and Senate governmental affairs committees in time for the 2017 regular session.
One learning lesson comes courtesy of Treasurer John Kennedy, who reported to the Louisiana Ethics Administration in February that his state campaign finance account contained $2.8 million. But Kennedy, a candidate for the U.S. Senate, cannot use any of that cash to run for federal office this year. That’s because state-sanctioned donations are prohibited from being used in federal campaigns, and vice versa.
U.S. Sen. David Vitter, who is vacating his seat, faced the same challenge last year when he was running for governor. He had a load of donations in his federal campaign account, but was unable to use the money in his bid for governor, a state race. So Vitter found a legal workaround—he donated the money he had raised as a United States senator to a super PAC that had been formed independently to support his candidacy for governor.
Kennedy has done the same thing this year, except he has donated money from his state campaign account to a super PAC called ESAFund, which will in turn be spending the cash in the U.S. Senate race to boost the treasurer’s profile and, more than likely, attack his opponents. It is perfectly legal and, quite frankly, it represents the new frontier for financing modern political campaigns. Kennedy is not the first to transfer campaign money in such a way and he will not be the last. In fact, similar transfers from other candidates should be expected in the coming months.
But here’s the rub. Since Kennedy is not up for re-election this year for treasurer, he only has to file annual reports to the Louisiana Ethics Administration. That means we won’t be able to see exactly how much he donated to his allied super PAC, or what he is currently spending his state-sanctioned donations on, until early 2017. By then Kennedy will have either been elected to the U.S. Senate or he’ll still be treasurer.
A simple solution would be for the state to transition to quarterly reporting deadlines, instead of annual submissions in non-election years. The Federal Election Commission already requires reports be filed in January, April, July and October. Louisiana should follow suit. And not because of the situation involving Kennedy, but rather in the interest of good government.
Funding would certainly be an issue. How would the state Ethics Administration be able to financially handle the increased workload? The most common sense approach would be for campaigns to foot the bill.
It’s not as if campaigns in Louisiana these days can’t spare the money. Plus, regulations can be drafted in such a way that any fine created is proportional to the amount of money being raised. In doing so, lawmakers won’t be forced to erect even more barriers for those who want to run for public office without establishment support.
Just think about last year’s race for governor, which was the most expensive ever waged. Candidates, super PACs, political parties and other groups spent nearly $50 million trying to influence the outcome. The top four candidates alone spent a collective $30 million.
Campaign fundraising has become a major industry in Louisiana and it deserves the scrutiny applied to any other multi-million dollar trade. Moreover, any candidate with the best interest of the state in mind couldn’t possibly oppose issues of transparency. If it’s worth it to spend thousands of dollars on signage to make sure voters know their choices, then it’s definitely worth it to spend a fraction of that to update Louisiana’s campaign finance reporting system.
Whether you like what’s happening in the world of campaign finance or if you’re disturbed by it, there’s little that can be done to slow down the train. After all, money is what fuels American politics. Information, though, is just as valuable and there’s nothing wrong with insisting that candidates give us more of it on a regular basis.
Jeremy Alford publishes LaPolitics Weekly, a newsletter on Louisiana politics at LaPolitics.com. Follow him on Twitter, or on Facebook. He can be reached at JJA@LaPolitics.com.
