The legislative session has started, and “the battle” has begun. We’ll be hearing about a lot of different issues, often described with titles and terms that are confusing or intended to disguise the real agenda. But when it comes right down to it, most of these bills and the positions people take on them are based on fundamental beliefs about freedom and the role of the individual versus that of government. In simplest terms: conservative vs. socialist—oops—I mean “liberal”; free enterprise vs. socialist—oh, I did it again—I meant “unions”; and angels vs. the devil.
OK, maybe I’m kidding now, but one state representative [and I won’t mention Pat Smith by name] was using that term in what seemed like a reference to the elected leader of Louisiana. [Well, while I am on her grandstanding performance to the media in front of the Capitol and Southern University protesters last week, let me say once again that Rep. Pat Smith harmed the future of many children as an EBR school board member and is doing it again as a legislator. I have seen the “devil” and she has red hair and wears a dress. Now I’m not kidding.]
So, let me just point out a few of the key issues and players, as I see them, and you decide which side you’re on:
Teacher tenure. Chas Roemer, a member of the Board of Elementary and Secondary Education from our area, said recently in a letter to legislators, “We should treat teachers like professionals. Good teachers need better pay and significantly better pay. The single most critical factor in educating our kids is a quality teacher. No other issue comes close. Barriers to ensuring quality teachers should be torn down.” Any argument with that?
He also pointed out a Stanford University study that says a good teacher can teach one and a half years’ worth of information in a single year, while a poorly performing teacher will only teach one-half of a year’s information in a year. Roemer notes, the vast majority of our teachers are of high quality and are underappreciated.
But Roemer also shared some other stats with me. He said, “One-third of the state’s approximately 600,000 kids in K-12 are below grade level. The labor unions—aka the teacher unions—argue that tenure is nothing more than due process. I would argue it’s become a system that protects poorly performing teachers. In 2008, of the 45,000-plus teachers in this state, only two were dismissed due to incompetence.”
Did you get that? Two out of 45,000. That’s less than 1/200th of 1%.
Roemer sent the letter referred to above to all legislators and BESE members and asked them to sign a statement of support to end teacher tenure in our state and mail it back to him. Would you sign it?
So what was the unions’ response? The Advocate reported, “[Louisiana Association of Educators] President Joyce Haynes said state lawmakers have rightly decided not to tamper with the issue. ‘They understand due process, but they are being told by someone else it is a problem. It is not a problem.’” Louisiana Federation of Teachers President Steve Monaghan told The Advocate that Roemer’s comments show he does not understand how the state’s teacher tenure law works. “But to say to eradicate tenure altogether is a red herring,” Monaghan said.
Wrong, Steve. In March, Florida Gov. Rick Scott signed new reform legislation to create merit pay and end teacher tenure for new hires. In an Associated Press story, former Washington, D.C., public schools Chancellor Michelle Rhee praised the legislation, stating, “This landmark bill recognizes that teachers are the most important factor in schools when determining a child’s success.” Of course, the unions opposed it and are deciding if they will sue in court.
If you haven’t decided yet which side you are on, let me share one other fact about tenure in Louisiana. Did you know that school bus drivers employed by a local school board for three years get tenure, too? That’s right. [See § 17:492, probation and tenure of bus operators.]
Maybe now it’s clear where you stand on this critical issue, but how about your legislator or BESE member? Ask them before you vote this fall.
Grading schools. This fall, parents would be getting a letter grade [A-F] for their child’s school based on a law passed in 2010. But “liberal” Sen. Yvonne Dorsey has filed a bill to delay that until at least the 2013-14 school year. It’s yet another ploy to avoid accountability.
While proponents and reformers think a delay would be harmful to children and unfair to parents, there are liberal groups and unions joining together to roll back the law.
A new group, Coalition for Louisiana Public Education, includes, among others, both teacher unions, the school boards association, school superintendents, school executives and retired teachers. I know where I have seen these folks before: They’re the ones who have been in charge of our public schools for the last 50 years. Haynes, president of the LAE, says she is tired of the misinformation. Well, I am tired of these folks telling the public their No. 1 concern is children—because it is not. This is a jobs issue to them—and that is not misinformation.
So what do you think and where do you stand? Should parents get the school grades this fall?
Taxes. Gov. Bobby Jindal has been crystal clear on his conservative position: no new taxes. Have government make do with what it has, just as a family during a recession must do. Adjust spending to match revenue.
Along comes another “coalition” calling for $940 million in new taxes. Are you ready to pay?
This group is filled with liberals and unions. The Advocate reported it includes 39 members, including the LFT, the Louisiana Budget Project, the Greater Baton Rouge AFL-CIO, the Louisiana Association of Nonprofit Organizations, Louisiana NAACP and the AARP.
One of their spokespersons, Eddie Ashworth, director of the “liberal” Louisiana Budget Project, made its position very clear when he told The Advocate, “The problem is not spending, it is revenue.”
Ashworth added, “The governor has been on a three-year jihad against government spending.” And that’s a problem? There are conservatives who are standing and cheering right now.
I know Ashworth and like him personally. But, as I said, how you feel about this legislative session, governor, or even president, is a matter of your beliefs and philosophy on the role of government versus individual freedoms and responsibilities.
You know where I stand. I am curious where you stand.
