Bar fight

Author Profile Image
Sign up for the free Daily Report email – local news about the people, companies and issues that impact business impact business in Baton Rouge and beyond.

With hopes of creating a more fair, reliable and consistent Louisiana Bar Exam, the state’s Supreme Court Committee on Bar Admissions is proposing the first significant changes to the test in about 60 years.

The changes represent such a complete overhaul of the exam’s scoring and structure that Jack Weiss, chancellor of LSU’s Paul M. Hebert Law Center, fears the state’s unique civil code will slowly erode.

“It’s been a longstanding policy of this state to require people who are licensed to practice law here to demonstrate their competency in Louisiana on the bar exam,” he says. “This proposal, as it stands, does not provide assurance that that will continue to be true.”

Advertisement

There are plenty of lawyers, judges and professors who share Weiss’ view. But Southern University Law Center Chancellor Freddie Pitcher Jr. isn’t one of them.

“The weight is still about 67% of Louisiana code material, and that’s sufficient to make sure an individual is well rounded in Louisiana law,” he says. “The folks who are ballyhooing about testing on the Louisiana trading, I just don’t think that’s a real issue.”

Louisiana law, and its bar exam, have a number of unique distinctions. Louisiana is the only state that doesn’t base its laws solely on English common law. Instead, Louisiana law is a gumbo of common law and civil law with roots in French, Roman and Spanish legal codes.

With such a distinctive approach, perhaps it’s only fitting that Louisiana’s bar exam is equally without peer. Other than Washington, which announced last month it will begin changing its bar exam starting in July 2013, Louisiana is the only state in which the exam is composed only of essays.

That would change in 2015 to include three types of tests, one of which would be the Multistate Bar Exam, a 200-question, multiple-choice test currently administered in every state but Louisiana and Washington.

Questions about Louisiana’s criminal code, procedure and evidence would be shifted into the MBE under the change, Weiss says, which means prospective lawyers likely will pay less attention to them. In turn, LSU and other law schools might have to do the same in order to adequately prepare students for the bar exam.

Weiss and Pitcher say their institutions don’t teach just to the exam.

“The bar exam has a huge influence on the development of our state’s law,” Weiss says. “Deemphasizing Louisiana law on the bar exam would, over a period of time, tend to deemphasize Louisiana law in the courts and, so to speak, we would deemphasize it in our curriculum. All of these things are related.”

Pitcher says there’s too much subjectivity in the essay format, which keeps some applicants who might otherwise be qualified from passing the bar, adding that eliminating it would allow for increased consistency and fairness. He says it also would pave the way for Louisiana’s exam to have some reciprocity with other states, of which there currently is none.

“Really, the big issues are going to be the drafting of the exams and who will be involved,” Pitcher says. “I really don’t think incorporating the multistate part of the exam would really be a hindrance to our students or to Louisiana tradition.”

The bar admissions committee recommends changing how the exam is scored, beginning in February 2012. Instead of having to pass seven of the nine tests that compose the exam, applicants would need to average 70% on all of the tests.

There’s also much debate about whether or not the changes would make the bar easier to pass. The committee’s data shows passage rates among first-time applicants in 2010 would have been 78% under the new scoring system, instead of 69%. But the committee maintains that statistic doesn’t mean the exam would be easier.

Michael Patterson, president of the Louisiana State Bar Association and a partner with Long Law Firm, agrees.

“A lot of lawyers say that they’re going to make the exam easier, and that’s one of their main concerns,” he says. “I personally don’t agree with that. Common sense tells me when you’re adding more components to the exam that it’s not going to be easier.”

Weiss isn’t convinced by such arguments, citing evidence that shows the exam will be easier to pass. Going through a presentation that he made in December to the Louisiana State Bar Association’s Board of Governors, Weiss says that a number of exams on which applicants failed as many as four of five Louisiana civil code tests would still pass under the new scoring model.

“They’re so preoccupied with statistical reliability that they’re willing to throw out the baby with the bathwater,” he says. “The test reliability tail is wagging the dog of what we ought to be teaching.”

Pitcher acknowledges there are some unsettling statistical possibilities such as those Weiss points out, adding they just aren’t probable in practice.

“It’s something that could happen, but it’s very unlikely that it will happen because most students are going into the exam trying to pass everything,” Pitcher says. “It’s not like we are opening up the floodgates and letting in new lawyers who are incompetent to practice.”

A showdown is scheduled for October, when the bar admissions committee discusses its final proposals to the Louisiana Supreme Court, representatives from Louisiana law schools and the state bar association. The committee plans to submit final proposals in November. Meanwhile, the bar association has its committee reviewing the changes with help from a hired independent expert.

The bar association committee says the changes are 10 years in the making; Weiss says there are “probably 100 other options out there” that haven’t been explored. Though he concedes the exam could be more consistent and he agrees with some of the smaller changes, he says there hasn’t been enough independent analysis to support a sweeping overhaul.

“If this is done the right way—if these alternatives are considered and someone independent says, ‘Here are some changes that protect Louisiana law and achieve greater reliability and consistency’—then I believe instead of having a controversy over this, we could very well have consensus support for improvement of the bar exam,” he says. “I just don’t think this job is anywhere near complete.”

AT A GLANCE
Changes to the bar exam as proposed by the ?Louisiana Supreme Court Committee on Bar Admissions:

Scoring method
Current: Nine tests are given as part of the bar exam, five of which focus on the Louisiana Civil Code. To pass, applicants must score 70% or higher on seven of the nine tests, as well as four of five civil code tests. This is called a conjunctive approach. Also, if an applicant passes at least five of the nine tests, it is considered a “conditional failure,” and they can take the failed tests again toward passage of seven of nine for bar admittance.
Proposed: Effective February 2012, cores on all nine tests would be combined, with applicants needing a 70% average to pass. This is called a compensatory approach. The “conditional failure” would be eliminated.

Test format
Current: All nine tests are in essay form, and applicants take them over three nonconsecutive days in one week, totaling 21.5 hours.
Proposed: Effective February 2015, the exam would encompass three forms: essay, short written responses and the multiple-choice Multistate Performance Test. Applicants would take the exam over three consecutive days, totaling 18 hours.

HAVE YOUR SAY: The Louisiana Supreme Court is accepting comments on proposed changes to the bar exam from members of the Louisiana State Bar Association and the public through March 15. Comments can be addressed to Lauren McHugh Rocha by mail to Louisiana Supreme Court, 400 Royal St., Ste. 1190, New Orleans, La., 70130; or by e-mail at lmchugh@lajao.org.

Discussion (0)

From Our Partners

Daily Report Poll

ASK AI

Ask anything about Baton Rouge business