In response to the novel and deadly coronavirus, many governments deployed severe and broad restrictions on daily activity that helped send the world into its deepest peacetime slump since the Great Depression.
Despite this steep price, few policymakers felt they had a choice, seeing the economic crisis as a side effect of the health crisis, The Wall Street Journal reports. They ordered nonessential businesses closed and told people to stay home. Faced with a poorly understood and rapidly spreading, deadly pathogen, they prioritized saving lives.
Five months later, the evidence suggests lockdowns were an overly blunt and economically costly tool. They are politically difficult to keep in place for long enough to stamp out the virus. Evidence also points to alternative strategies that could slow the spread of the epidemic at much less cost. As cases continue to flare up throughout the U.S., some experts are urging policymakers to pursue these more targeted restrictions and interventions rather than another crippling round of lockdowns.
“We’re on the cusp of an economic catastrophe,” says James Stock, a Harvard University economist who, with Harvard epidemiologist Michael Mina and others, is modeling how to avoid a surge in deaths without a deeply damaging lockdown. “We can avoid the worst of that catastrophe by being disciplined,” Stock says.
Social distancing policies, for instance, can take into account widely varying risks by age. The virus is especially deadly for the elderly. Nursing homes account for 0.6% of the population but 45% of COVID-19 fatalities, says the Foundation for Research on Equal Opportunity, a free market think tank. Better isolating those residents would have saved many lives at little economic cost, it says. Read the full story.
