While most leaders within Baton Rouge remain united in their support for a highway loop around the city, opposition has long simmered in areas where the multi-billion dollar highway might actually run. April 2010 might be remembered as the month when opponents gained the upper hand, as three of the five parish presidents officially announced they were dropping out of the Capital Area Expressway Authority.
“I’ve been saying that the Loop has been on life support, and I think the plug has been pulled now,” says state Sen. Dale Erdey, a Livingston Republican.
But supporters haven’t given up, so maybe the project has flatlined but isn’t dead yet. In this metaphor, Mayor Kip Holden and Baton Rouge legislators are standing over the Loop, rubbing the defibrillator paddles together and shouting “Clear!” before attempting to shock the patient back to life.
“I hope it’s not dead,” says Rep. Steve Carter, a Baton Rouge Republican who chairs the Capital Region Legislative Delegation. “A number of us within the Baton Rouge area are very supportive of it. We’re going to try to figure out a way to keep it alive.”
The southern and eastern legs of what would have been the Loop are off the table for now. Officials are pushing for a 25-mile northern bypass through Livingston, East Baton Rouge and West Baton Rouge parishes. The northern bypass is considered the most economically feasible portion, since it’s the cheapest to build from an environmental perspective and would attract the most traffic, thereby raising the most money in tolls.
The Baton Rouge Area Chamber and others are seeking $5 million in state money over two years to fund an environmental study for the bypass, including $2 million this year and $3 million next year. The study would examine the impact on communities and the natural environment to help determine the highway’s best path. The delegation did not endorse the funding request as a group for the current legislative session, and the money is not in the initial state budget proposal. Carter and Sen. Dan Claitor, another Baton Rouge Republican, say getting the money might still be?possible even without support from their colleagues in surrounding areas.
According to Walter Monsour, Holden’s former second-in-command and still a spokesman for the Loop project, the northern bypass will deflect about 56,000 vehicles a day, primarily from Interstate 12. East-west traffic between Slidell and Houston, to pick two points on either side, could skip the 10/12 split entirely.
Construction costs, which skyrocketed after Hurricane Katrina, are coming down, and the project now calls for refurbishing the existing U.S. 190 bridge instead of building a new one; Monsour says the bypass can come in at about $757 million. At that cost, the project pays for itself with tolls, he says, meaning the state wouldn’t have to cough up any tax revenue past the aforementioned $5 million. The model assumes a toll of 15 cents a mile, or $3.75 one-way from end to end. Local drivers, like Monsour’s assistant who now spends nearly two-and-a-half hours a day commuting between Watson and downtown, would be more than willing to pay to cut that time in half, he says.
“We created the Capital Area Expressway Authority to get the support of the local [parish] presidents,” Monsour says. “At the time, there was clearly a unanimity of support.” But now Ascension’s Tommy Martinez, Livingston’s Mike Grimmer, and Iberville’s Mitchell Ourso Jr. have pulled out, leaving only Holden and West Baton Rouge’s Riley Berthelot still backing the project.
But even with unanimous support, the Louisiana Transportation Authority would have had to approve the new toll road, Monsour says, and the LTA still has the final say. While the LTA is a political body created by the Legislature, he says that doesn’t mean they’ll be swayed one way or the other by the elected representatives of the Capital Region.
“The whole premise of having the LTA there is to take a more holistic viewpoint,” Monsour says. “These bypasses affect the entire state. … This can’t get bogged down in local neighborhood politics.”
Rep. Bodi White, a Denham Springs Republican, opposes the Loop, including the northern bypass. He doesn’t think commuters will pay $3 to $4 one way to go to work every day, which could quickly add up to more than $100 a month. He says studies he’s seen show the northern bypass would only take about 10,000 cars from I-12 and cost well over $1 billion.
Rep. Mert Smiley, a Port Vincent Republican, also worries about funding. The private partner will want a guaranteed profit; if tolls don’t cover the cost, local governments will be left to make up the difference, he says.
“There is some confusion about [the funding model],” Smiley says. “I am under the impression that you wouldn’t be able to build a four-lane highway within a certain distance of the Loop because that would take away from the profits of the Loop.”
Smiley isn’t necessarily against tolls. Several officials on both sides of this issue say tolling new roads, while not exactly popular, is more palatable than other options like increasing income taxes or the gasoline tax. At least with tolls, the people who use the road pay for it, which seems only fair, some say.
A legacy project?
If the Loop dies, what does that say about Holden’s legacy? The mayor remains personally popular, but his big initiatives have sputtered, including two attempts at a major bond issue. Political consultant Roy Fletcher says he doesn’t think blame for a failed Loop will blow back on Holden.
In some areas, Loop opponents are the majority. But even if they’re the minority in a given district, parish or region, they are potentially a highly motivated voting block, especially if they’re going to be directly affected. South Baton Rouge residents were just as upset as today’s opponents when a similar project was proposed in their backyard in the late 1990s. The political calculus typically dictates catering to the NIMBYs, Fletcher says.
“Kip really doesn’t have any control over that,” he says. “It may very well be that out in those parishes, the harder he would push, the more they would see it as a Baton Rouge thing and be even more against it.”
Holden does a great job one-on-one and in small groups; but outside of his election, he’s so far been unable to inspire the masses, public relations consultant Randy Hayden says.
“If you can’t inspire this community on projects that are relatively immediate [like the bond issue], how are you going to inspire people to support a project that many of them won’t even be around for by the time the project is finished?” he says. Still, Hayden suggests Holden may be up to the task.
Many people on both sides of the issue agree Baton Rouge should have had a loop decades ago. Shreveport has multiple bypasses and Lake Charles has one, proponents say, but not Baton Rouge?
“I don’t want to be sitting here 20 years from now saying, ‘Well, we could never get that Loop done,’” says Rep. Hunter Greene, a Baton Rouge Republican.
Opponents turn that same argument around. Perhaps a loop did make sense 30 or 40 years ago, when more farms than subdivisions surrounded the city, they say. But today building such a project anywhere near Baton Rouge could require buying out or expropriating large swaths of established neighborhoods, an expensive and painful process. Move it too far out from the city, and the traffic counts don’t justify the cost. It may be that the Loop, good idea or not, is simply too late.
“Our time may have passed,” Fletcher says.
The express way
Opponents of the Baton Rouge Loop say there are several smaller projects that could help to alleviate some of the region’s traffic woes without costing billions or displacing many people.
One of the most popular ideas with folks on the south side of the region is working its way through the legislative process. State Sen. Jody Amedee, a Gonzales Democrat, calls it the “West Bank Expressway.” Broadly speaking, the expressway might connect with Interstate 10 in Port Allen, then parallel La. Highway 1 and La. 3127 all the way to U.S. 90 in Boutte.
Supporters say the state already owns most of the needed rights of way. Ascension Parish President Tommy Martinez has suggested putting tolls on the Sunshine Bridge and the Gramercy-Wallace Bridge to pay for the expressway.
“It could pay for itself,” he says, “and you wouldn’t have to look for money every year.”
Walter Monsour, the former administrator for Mayor Kip Holden’s office, says he doubts a West Bank expressway would make a big dent in interstate traffic because most drivers aren’t headed to New Orleans.
Other suggestions being kicked around include:
• A Hooper Road extension across the Amite River to La. 1019 in Watson.
• A toll road connecting Ascension and Livingston parishes, perhaps extending from the north end of La. 44 and connecting with Walker South Road [La. 447] somewhere south of Interstate 12.
• Extending South Harrell’s Ferry Road into Livingston Parish.
• Widening La. 30 so that it becomes a four-lane highway from downtown all the way to Airline Highway in Ascension Parish.
• Widening U.S. 190 and U.S. 61.
• Further widening of I-10 and I-12 is always popular. State Sen. Dale Erdey, a Livingston Republican, has even suggested an elevated highway, stacked on top of I-12. He admits it would be expensive, but at least the state wouldn’t need a lot of new real estate. Erdey says the idea might be worth examining if the Loop is no longer considered viable.
