A canal runs through it

Author Profile Image
Sign up for the free Daily Report email – local news about the people, companies and issues that impact business impact business in Baton Rouge and beyond.

The history of the Comite River Diversion Canal is as tangled as the river itself.

Congress approved the 12-mile canal in 1992 to channel 20,000 cubic feet of water per second to the Mississippi River, lowering flood stages along the Comite and Amite rivers in East Baton Rouge, Ascension and Livingston parishes.

But 19 years and $71 million later, the Amite River Basin Commission is caught between a U.S. Army Corps of Engineers ultimatum and a new law that could cause the project to be scrapped. The corps won’t move forward with construction until the commission purchases 700 acres along the river in a 2,400-acre mitigation area.

Advertisement

“There is the risk of ultimate failure of the project,” ARBC attorney Larry Bankston says. “That’s a real possibility, and we’re certainly not trying to cry wolf. We have a very serious problem.”

A total of 1,700 acres is needed to offset environmental impacts of the project, which were outlined in the original 1995 agreement. The 700 acres in question would offset work on the canal’s largest feature, the $30 million Lilly Bayou control structure, which was completed earlier this year.

The structure, a large concrete-lined quarry off West Irene Road, is designed to slow floodwater diverted from the Comite, about eight miles away, to the Mississippi.

“We are moving forward with design and engineering of the features to put ourselves in a position to move as quickly as possible on construction when the land is acquired,” says Bobby Duplantier, who is the corps’ project manager.

ARBC Executive Director Dietmar Rietschier says the ultimatum is unfair, considering that the corps was responsible for purchasing mitigation land until about six months ago, when the Department of Transportation and Development voided the corps’ agreement for mitigation acquisition because it had purchased just 67 acres since 2002.

Further complicating the acquisition efforts by DOTD and the basin commission is a 2010 law forbidding the expropriation of mitigation land for the project. State Rep. Bodi White, a Central Republican, says he sponsored the bill because constituents who don’t want to sell their property shouldn’t be forced to sell.

White says that allowing expropriation for the project would have set a bad precedent for other projects throughout Louisiana. He initally pushed for a statewide ban on expropriation for mitigation purchases, but that bill failed to move out of committee.

“Once you start allowing expropriation here,” he says, “what’s going to stop you from doing it anywhere else?”

ARBC now is striking back with a bill of its own, written by Bankston and sponsored by Reps. Mert Smiley, a St. Amant Republican, and Frank Howard, a Many Republican, that would restore expropriation power. It also would ensure access to the canal for people who are forced to sell their property at assessed values and prohibit the development of public recreation features in the area, which are sticking points in the expropriation debate.

The commission also has filed suit to overturn the expropriation ban. The agency is taking a two-prong attack, Rietschier says, because it’s not confident that it can obtain the required mitigation acreage without expropriation powers.

Earlier this month, White and the commission held three public meetings in Central and Zachary to gauge property owners’ interest in selling; some residents indicated that they would entertain offers. Even if enough of them agree to sell, there’s another hurdle: The corps is requiring 1,700 contiguous acres, so theoretically it’s possible for one person to break up the deal.

If it can’t acquire the acreage, ARBC will have to ask the corps to designate a new mitigation area. But doing so will require new environmental studies that could delay the project—already four years behind schedule—by another three to five years, according to corps estimates. The project’s cost, which has ballooned from $153 million a decade ago to about $200 million, also would undoubtedly increase.

White will meet with Col. Edward Fleming, commander of the corps’ New Orleans district, in an attempt to resolve the impasse. White says he’s confident the project will not be halted, adding that there are other options besides altering the mitigation area if enough property owners won’t sell.

“I feel sure that we’re in this too deep for [the corps] to pull the plug,” he says. “Some people say Bodi White is trying to stop the project. That’s bull. I’ve been working very hard to stand the project up and get it done. The corps has put us in a jam. … In my mind, they’ve broken every federal law there is.”

White and the commission say the corps ignored its own regulations requiring that mitigation lands are purchased concurrently with construction progress. When asked why the Lilly Bayou control structure was allowed to be completed before the corps had acquired the 700 acres now holding up further construction, Duplantier says, “We feel like we are in compliance with that regulation.”

If ARBC can’t find enough sellers and the corps halts construction, White says he’ll ask Attorney General Buddy Caldwell to intervene. White says he’s also meeting with the state’s congressional delegation, to prepare for the possibility that they must seek

federal appropriation to complete the project.

“This whole debate is silly, because we can make this mitigation problem go away today,” says Peter Couhig, executive vice president of Resource Environmental Solutions, a Baton Rouge-based mitigation bank.

RES has about 5,000 acres of mitigation land near the project, Couhig says, including four banks within a mile of the mitigation area. He says the mitigation banks could be used without the corps’ requiring a new environmental study, adding the required credits could be purchased for the $16.3 million budgeted for mitigation.

Rietschier says he’s looked into that option and wishes it were a possibility.

“If we were allowed to go beyond the mitigation perimeter, then we’d have a lot of other options, including mitigation banks,” Rietschier says. “But as it stands today, we’ve been told by the corps in absolute terms we have to work within the current perimeter or face new environmental studies.”

Voters in East Baton Rouge, Livingston and Ascension parishes approved a taxing district to help fund the diversion canal in 2000; the tax was renewed in 2010 for another decade despite little progress on the project. Even with the Lilly Bayou control structure in place, the project is far from complete: five roadway bridges, two railroad bridges, drop structures and the canal itself still need to be built.

The project could be finished by 2017 or 2018 if the mitigation lands can be acquired. Rietschier’s biggest concern, however, is that there will be another flood similar to the one in 1983 that led to ARBC’s creation. About 5,300 homes and 200 businesses in East Baton Rouge, Livingston and Ascension parishes were damaged when the Comite and Amite rivers spilled over their banks.

“We have always been the most exposed to the community because we’ve spearheaded this project all along,” Rietschier says. “If we have another flood, the people are going to come to us no matter how innocent we were or how hard we fought against all of these evil forces.”

Discussion (0)

From Our Partners

Daily Report Poll

ASK AI

Ask anything about Baton Rouge business