All in the family

All in the family

Monday, December 3, 2007

For the better part of the past decade, Baton Rouge has been fretting over how to retain and attract young, educated 20- and 30-something professionals, especially those in the so-called Creative Class.

Mind you, we really haven’t done anything to actually retain or attract these young urban single professionals (or Yuspies), but jaws ache from Spanish Town to Southdowns from all the talking we’ve done about what needs to happen to turn Baton Rouge—and downtown especially—into a cool city.

Nothing epitomizes our singular vocal focus more than the 328 forums and committee meetings on the creation of a downtown entertainment district. How’s that working out?

While many, including yours truly, have lamented the fact this city finds embracing change and embracing males equally repulsive, there’s growing evidence that suggests places that have actually done something to lure this “dream demographic” have little to show for it. My hometown of Baltimore, for example, is one of roughly a dozen cities that have installed the offense of the hip and cool, yet each has struggled to find the end zones of economic and demographic growth.

So if baby boomers aren’t getting it done anymore, and upwardly mobile singles are o-ver-rated, then where does our city turn its lonely eyes?

Well, analysis by an outfit called the Praxis Strategy Group, according to an opinion piece in the Wall Street Journal, shows the cities that are blowing and going—such as the Raleigh-Durham of canvass trip fame—are teeming with young, educated families with parents who range from their mid-20s to mid-40s.

Don’t believe them? Then why does research show places like New York, Boston, Chicago and Los Angeles—hot spots for the young and unconnected—have experienced below average job and population growth since 2000? Because middle-class families are fleeing those cities faster than players bolt from a John Brady-coached basketball team.

The wonks who study these things say couples with children are usually successful and motivated—and twice as likely to be in the top 20% of wage earners, according to the Census. Moreover, their incomes are rising faster than the national average. Hmmm … successful, motivated, well paid and hungry for more cash—sounds like the prerequisites for putting one’s children through private school.

Here’s another shocker: While vibrant downtowns remain important, the new and improved “dream demographic” prefer family-friendly suburbs with affordable housing, parks, trails and easy commutes. In other words, progressive thinking and quality of life demands can’t be the sole domain of the so-called downtown crowd.

Check out Portland, another canvass tour destination, which is loaded with both young singles and young families. Downtown remains a hot spot, but three-quarters of the area’s economic and residential growth is happening in the ‘burbs. Ask anyone who went on the trip and they’ll confirm it for you.

Young singles still flock to cities like Austin, Dallas and Atlanta. And young singles still flee from Baton Rouge. Yet many who leave do eventually return once a wedding band and a bambino join the family photo.

And getting more young families to settle in the Baton Rouge area is now the challenge for our future success.

The good news is Baton Rouge, like other cities along the 10/12 corridor, has a family-friendly reputation. The trick is to 1) get that word out to the rest of the nation while 2) addressing those things (public education, infrastructure and more varied quality of life options) that make “family-friendly” more fact than reputation.

So here’s the message to those in Forum 35 and other young professionals: If you want us to keep sucking up to you then get a master’s, get a job, get married and start having 2.5 children—and do it by the age of 42.


Comments

Posted by urbnplnnr on December 4, 2007 at 7:24 a.m. (Suggest removal)

Another way to attract and/or retain the Creative Class (and business) is by giving them the housing and lifestyle options they want. Bring on the TNDs. Go Rouzan!

Posted by Tara on December 5, 2007 at 8:30 p.m. (Suggest removal)

Urbnplnnr...You sound like you really believe Baton Rouge might be "the next great city" they keep saying it can be!

Posted by por_deni on December 7, 2007 at 12:54 p.m. (Suggest removal)

One small problem...the number of families with children is shrinking. Only 25% of households will contain children by 2030. How many can we really entice to Louisiana?
And I think "family friendly" Baton Rouge is a stretch. What about the poor public schools, few sidewalks, far-flung parks without easy access...
It is family-friendly to natives because grandparents are free babysitters!

Posted by trufree on December 7, 2007 at 1:46 p.m. (Suggest removal)

This is a no-brainer and shouldn't need a strategy group's analysis to be noticed. The assault on and demise of the nuclear family has increased poverty, illiteracy, crime, disease, and mental illness throughout the U.S. So play to B.R.'s traditional strengths and build on its politically incorrect---but morally sound---values: show that it's a place that welcomes wholesome values and church-going, traditional, committed families. But do so because it's the right thing to do. Not in the greedy, cynical name of economic gain.

Posted by tjm on December 7, 2007 at 2:11 p.m. (Suggest removal)

Amen. I'm so tired of hearing about downtown and how we need more things for singletons to do and see. I never go downtown unless it is for an event at the River Center (maybe once or twice a year). It is just to far to drive, and traffic is horrific, from where I live in Southeast Baton Rouge. I'm a single parent and I work in South Baton Rouge and live in Southeast Baton Rouge. All my friends live and work in Southeast Baton Rouge. Our children go to (public) school in Southeast Baton Rouge. Maybe if the Powers That Be in Baton Rouge government would concentrate on keeping the families already in East Baton Rouge Parish happy (good schools, good roads, etc.), maybe others would stay (instead of moving to Liv. and Asc. Parishes the second their children become school age). Those who stay in EBR will tell two friends, who tell two friends, and so on and so on.

Posted by Twiggy225 on December 7, 2007 at 8:11 p.m. (Suggest removal)

What annoys me are people like trufree. People who think that if you are not white, straight and Christian then you are the damnation of America. Let me tell you what I think is the damnation of America... people like trufree that are unaccepting and intolerant of others who may be different or have different views. This country was built on the believe that everyone was created equal regardless... where did we stray from that belief?

Posted by Jon_Deaux on December 8, 2007 at 1:16 p.m. (Suggest removal)

JR, I frankly thought I had you figured out…greatest apologies. Excellent editorial, not because I agreed with it but because it shows that there are other legitimate, progressive approaches to the development of a city.

While welcoming all people it is still very possible for us to maintain all that is good about our community. Even though I don’t fit into the typical Baton Rougeon mode (no children) I still recognize and appreciate the fact that we are a family oriented city. My hope for us is that as we grow we never lose sight of this as a core directive. I think that makes for a “Great City” as well.

Post a comment

(Requires free registration.)

Username:
Password: (Forgotten your password?)

Comment:

Story Extras

Poll

What best describes your spending habits for this Mother’s Day?

See Results | Archives



Click Here for Great Deals